StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Nancy's Organic Whole Milk Cottage Cheese vs Organic Valley Cottage Cheese 4%

Both are organic, whole-milk cottage cheese with 14 g of protein per half-cup, so the choice comes down to curd style and flavor. Nancy's is soft and creamy with a distinct tang and live cultures, and owners praise its texture. Organic Valley is small-curd, milder and more versatile for cooking. Buy Nancy's for eating straight from the tub; buy Organic Valley for recipes and a milder taste.

  • Choose the Nancy's if you want a creamy, tangy cottage cheese with live cultures to eat on its own.
  • Choose the Organic Valley if you want a mild small-curd cheese that works in cooking and baking.

Prices

  • Nancy's Organic Whole Milk Cottage Cheese: $7.49 at Amazon (checked today)
  • Organic Valley Cottage Cheese 4%: $6.99 at TheBetterHealthStore.com (checked today)
  • Difference: the Organic Valley Cottage Cheese 4% is $0.50 cheaper than the Nancy's Organic Whole Milk Cottage Cheese today
Nancy's
Cottage Cheese, Whole Milk, Nancy's, Organic, 16 oz

Nancy's Organic Whole Milk Cottage Cheese

Cottage Cheese, Whole Milk, Nancy's, Organic, 16 oz

$7.49at AmazonChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission. As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

Pros
  • Creamy, soft texture close to farmer's cheese
  • Tangy flavor that stands on its own
  • Live probiotic cultures
  • No gums or artificial thickeners
  • Lower sodium than the rival
Cons
  • Tart flavor is not for everyone
  • Fewer calories saved than the rival
  • Not the small-curd style some cooks want
Organic Valley
Organic Valley Cottage Cheese Full 4%

Organic Valley Cottage Cheese 4%

Organic Valley Cottage Cheese Full 4%

$6.99at TheBetterHealthStore.comChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit TheBetterHealthStore.com
Pros
  • Mild, fresh flavor suits many dishes
  • Small curd holds up in cooking and baking
  • Fewer calories per serving
  • Pasture-raised cows, no antibiotics or GMOs
  • Widely stocked and easy to find
Cons
  • Higher sodium per serving
  • More sugar and carbs than the rival
  • Milder taste can seem flat eaten plain

What separates them

Nancy's Organic Whole Milk Cottage CheeseOrganic Valley Cottage Cheese 4%
Curd styleSoft, creamy curds with a creamy dressingSmall curd
FlavorDistinctively tart and tangyMild and fresh
Sodium per serving300 mg450 mg
Calories per serving120110
CulturesBillions of live probiotic culturesLive and active cultures
AdditivesNo gums or artificial thickenersNo antibiotics, synthetic hormones or GMOs
Best useSnacking straight from the tubProtein meals, snacks and cooking
Carbohydrates3 g5 g

Price history

$6.99$4.69
Nov 15Nov 22
  • Nancy's Organic Whole Milk Cottage Cheese: lowest $5.45 on Nov 15 at DoorDash; $6.79 on Nov 22.
  • Organic Valley Cottage Cheese 4%: lowest $4.69 on Nov 22 at lifestylesin360.com.

Prices at every store

Nancy's Organic Whole Milk Cottage Cheese

  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $7.49Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Amazon
  • zerbos.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $8.05Checked 1 h ago
    Visit zerbos.com
  • DoorDashNew

    Availability unknownSold by The Fresh Market US

    $8.19Checked 1 h ago
    Visit DoorDash
  • InstacartNew

    Availability unknown

    $8.19Checked Nov 15
    Visit Instacart

Also available at

  • Whole Foods MarketCheck price at Whole Foods Market
  • TC FarmCheck price at TC Farm
  • SproutsCheck price at Sprouts

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 12 stores and price history →

Organic Valley Cottage Cheese 4%

  • Misfits MarketNew

    In stock

    $7.49Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Misfits Market
  • TheBetterHealthStore.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $6.99Checked 1 h ago
    Visit TheBetterHealthStore.com
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $6.99Checked Nov 15
    Visit Amazon
  • yokesfreshmarkets.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $7.29Checked 1 h ago
    Visit yokesfreshmarkets.com

Also available at

  • Hy-VeeCheck price at Hy-Vee
  • Basic FoodsCheck price at Basic Foods
  • lifestylesin360.comCheck price at lifestylesin360.com

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 11 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecNancy's Organic Whole Milk Cottage CheeseOrganic Valley Cottage Cheese 4%
Serving size1/2 CUP 110 Gram1/2 cup (110g)
Calories120110
Total fat6g5g
Saturated fat3g3g
Cholesterol15mg15mg
Sodium300mg450mg
Total carbohydrate3g5g
Total sugars3g4g
Protein14g14g
VarietyCottage CheeseCottage Cheese
TextureSoft, CreamySmall Curd
Cheese Weight16 oz16 oz
Show all 32 specsShow fewer specs
SpecNancy's Organic Whole Milk Cottage CheeseOrganic Valley Cottage Cheese 4%
Milk TypeCowCow
Fat ContentWhole milk4% Milkfat
Free OfGluten-freeToxic pesticides, Antibiotics, GMOs, Synthetic …
Cheese FormCurds, Creamy dressingSmall Curd
Storage TypeRefrigeratedRefrigerated
With FruitNoNo
Protein Content14 g14 g
Typical UsersVegetarian-friendlyVegetarian
CertificationsOrganicOrganic

Questions and answers

Which is better for eating plain?
Nancy's. Its creamy texture and tangy flavor are built for snacking straight from the tub. Organic Valley is milder and better suited to recipes.
Which works better in cooking?
Organic Valley. Its small curds hold their shape in lasagna, pancakes and dips, and the mild flavor blends in.
Does either have live cultures?
Yes. Nancy's lists billions of live probiotic cultures, and Organic Valley contains live and active cultures.
Which has less sodium?
Nancy's, at 300 mg per half-cup against 450 mg for Organic Valley.
Is one worth stepping up to?
If you eat cottage cheese plain and like a tang, Nancy's is worth it. If you cook with it or prefer mild flavor, Organic Valley is the better fit.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Organic Valley Cottage Cheese Full 4% vs 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Cottage Cheese, 16 oz
  • Good Culture Organic Whole Milk Classic Cottage Cheese, 16oz vs Organic Valley Cottage Cheese Full 4%
  • Cottage Cheese, Whole Milk, Nancy's, Organic, 16 oz vs 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Cottage Cheese, 16 oz
  • Organic Valley Cottage Cheese Full 4% vs Good Culture Organic Low-Fat Cottage Cheese
  • Good Culture Organic Whole Milk Classic Cottage Cheese, 16oz vs Cottage Cheese, Whole Milk, Nancy's, Organic, 16 oz

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best organic cottage cheese
Ripened
Fully cultured
Fresh
Packaging TypeContainerContainer
Container size16 oz—
Servings per container4—
Milkfat minimum4% milkfat minimum—
Cheese FirmnessSoft—
Cheese FlavorPlain, Unflavored—
ContainsSalt, Milk—
Milkfat—4%
Curd style—Small Curd
Package weight—1 lb