Craftsman 230-Piece Home Tool Kit vs DeWalt DWMT81534 205-Piece Mechanics Tool Set

The DeWalt DWMT81534 is the better-built set for serious mechanical work. Its 72-tooth ratchets with a 5-degree arc swing reach fasteners the Craftsman's coarser ratchets can't, and it covers all three drive sizes (1/4, 3/8, 1/2 inch) with a full lifetime warranty. The Craftsman 230-piece kit wins on sheer count and breadth of included tools like extension bars and universal joints, and its higher owner rating suggests buyers are satisfied. Pick the DeWalt if you turn wrenches often; pick the Craftsman if you want one big case covering the widest range of jobs.

• Choose the Craftsman 230-Piece Home Tool Kit if you want the most pieces in one case and a broad mix of wrenches, extensions and universal joints for general home and auto repair.
• Choose the DeWalt DWMT81534 if you do regular mechanical work and want fine-tooth ratchets, all three drive sizes and a lifetime warranty.