Crate & Barrel Lounge Sofa vs Room & Board York Sofa

The Crate & Barrel Lounge is the deeper, softer sofa: 24-inch seat depth, fiber-down back cushions and a 37-inch back make it the one to sink into. The Room & Board York is the longer, lower, more upright sofa at 98 inches wide with a 23-inch seat and 19-inch seat height, and its stain-resistant Sumner fabric suits households that worry about spills. Build is solid on both: kiln-dried hardwood frames, FSC-certified wood on the Lounge. Owners rate the Lounge highly (4.5 from over 3,600 ratings) and praise its comfort; the York's loose, blend-down cushions need regular fluffing and its 309-pound capacity is modest for a sofa this long.

• Choose the Crate & Barrel Lounge if you want a deep, cushioned sofa for curling up and movie nights, and you value a custom fabric choice and a long track record of owner ratings.
• Choose the Room & Board York if you want a longer, lower sofa with a firmer, more upright sit, stain-resistant upholstery and loose cushions you can rotate and clean.