Nine West Dorra Mesh Mary Jane Flats vs Hannah Mary Jane Ballet Flats

The Dorra is the lighter, more breathable pick, and its sheer mesh with gold-tone ornament gives it a dressier look. The Hannah is the more conventional everyday flat, with a smooth closed upper and a slim adjustable strap and buckle. The Dorra's mesh and textile outsole are the weaker points for daily wear and wet pavement, and the Hannah's smooth upper holds its shape better over time. Buy the Dorra for warm-weather wear and a bit of texture; buy the Hannah for a plain black flat you can wear most days.

• Choose the Dorra Mesh Mary Jane if you want a light, breathable flat with a sheer mesh look and gold-tone hardware for warm days and dressed-up outfits.
• Choose the Hannah Mary Jane if you want a simple, smooth black flat with an adjustable strap and buckle that works with almost everything.