Maple Leopard Mary Jane Ballet Flats vs Nine West Dorra Mesh Mary Jane Flats

Buy the Maple Leopard if you want a real leather flat with a low heel and a print that reads as a neutral. Buy the Dorra if you want a lighter, breathable mesh flat that sits nearly flat. The Maple Leopard has the better build: leather upper, lining and sock, plus a synthetic sole and a 1-2 inch heel. The Dorra is mesh over textile with a man-made sock and a round toe, so it is cooler on hot days but less durable and less structured. Owners of leather Mary Janes like the Maple generally report they hold shape and wear well barefoot; mesh flats draw praise for breathability and complaints about snags.

• Choose the Maple Leopard if you want a leather-lined Mary Jane with a small heel, a square toe and a leopard print that works with plain outfits.
• Choose the Dorra if you want a near-flat, lightweight mesh Mary Jane with gold-tone hardware and a round toe for warm weather.