Which is better for everyday wear?

The 8065. Its Crazy Horse leather takes Wonder Balsam care, the double straps adjust to your foot, and it costs $58.50 at Zappos.com as of November 3, 2026. The Elphie II's hair-on print is more delicate and needs a soft brush only.

Both are Goodyear welted, so both soles can be replaced. The 8065's oil-finished leather is easier to maintain and buff back into shape, which usually means a longer useful life than a hair-on print.

Is the Elphie II worth the extra?

Only if you want the leopard print. No price was given for the Elphie II, while the 8065 is $58.50 at Zappos.com as of November 3, 2026, so the 8065 is the better value on construction and care.

How do the sizes run?

The 8065 uses UK sizing: US women order 2 sizes smaller (US 7 = UK 5). The Elphie II follows standard Dr. Martens sizing, so check the size chart before ordering either.

Are they good for wide feet?

The 8065 has a wider footbed and more rounded toe per the product page, and its double buckles adjust. The Elphie II has a single strap, so fit is less adjustable.

Can I wear either in rain?

Leather uppers handle light rain, but neither is a waterproof boot. Dry wet Crazy Horse leather away from direct heat and reapply Wonder Balsam; keep the Elphie II's hair-on print dry.

Dr. Martens Elphie II Mary Jane Shoes vs Dr Martens Women's 8065 Mary Jane Dark Brown Crazy Horse Leather

The 8065 is the safer buy for most shoppers: it is a real leather Mary Jane with Goodyear welted construction, and at $58.50 at Zappos.com as of November 3, 2026 it costs far less than the Elphie II. The Elphie II is the pick only if you want the leopard hair-on print and a lighter, more decorative look. Neither is a running shoe; both are casual leather Mary Janes on Dr. Martens soles.

Ask our shopping agent