Dr. Martens Women's Polley vs Dr. Martens Elphie II Mary Jane Shoes
Both are Dr. Martens Mary Janes with Goodyear-welted soles, but they solve different problems. The Polley is the practical pick: plain black leather, T-strap buckle, slip-resistant Airwair sole, and a best new price of $119.95 at eBay as of November 3, 2026. The Elphie II is the statement pick, with leopard hair-on leather that needs a soft brush and no polish. Buy the Polley for daily wear; buy the Elphie II if you want the print.
Ask our shopping agent
Dr. Martens Women's Polley
4.5$119.95at eBayObserved Nov 2, 2026, 2:48 PM
Choose the Dr. Martens Polley if you want a plain black leather Mary Jane you can wear to work or travel and wipe clean, at $119.95 at eBay as of November 3, 2026.
Pros
- Slip-resistant rubber sole handles wet pavement and greasy floors.
- Plain black leather works with most outfits and cleans up easily.
- Leather lining and cushioned footbed suit long days on your feet.
- Goodyear welted, so the sole can be replaced.
- Price is known and tracked: $119.95 at eBay as of November 3, 2026.
Cons
- Only one color, black.
What separates them
| Dr. Martens Women's Polley | Dr. Martens Elphie II Mary Jane Shoes | |
|---|---|---|
| Upper | Smooth black Airwair leather, semi-bright finish | Leopard-print hair-on cow leather |
| Sole | Rubber Airwair sole, oil- and fat-resistant, slip-resistant | PVC sole, Goodyear welted |
| Closure | T-strap with buckle | Mary Jane strap (buckle) |
| Lining | Leather lining | 80% leather, 20% textile |
| Care | Standard leather care, polish and condition | Brush gently with a soft hair brush only |
| Weight | 1 lb 7.1 oz per shoe | Not published |
| Color options | Black | Leopard print |
| Price | $119.95 at eBay as of November 3, 2026 |
Price history
$111.38$56.00
- Dr. Martens Women's Polley: lowest $105.19 on Oct 30 at SVD-sivasdescalzo; $111.38 on Nov 3.
- Dr. Martens Elphie II Mary Jane Shoes: lowest $56.00 on Nov 2 at Amazon.
Prices at every store
Dr. Martens Women's Polley
- Zappos.comNew
In stock
$150.00Observed at 4:17 AM - eBayNew
Availability unknownSold by somethingwithsole
$119.95Observed Nov 2, 2026, 2:48 PM - Atom RetroNew
Availability unknown
$200.00Observed Nov 2, 2026, 2:48 PM
Also available at
- EtsyCheck price at Etsy
- WalmartCheck price at Walmart
- Dr. Martens USCheck price at Dr. Martens US
Specs compared
| Spec | Dr. Martens Women's Polley | Dr. Martens Elphie II Mary Jane Shoes |
|---|---|---|
| Width | Width Medium | — |
| Material | Genuine Leather, Rubber | — |
| Strap Style | T-strap | — |
| Slip Resistant | Yes | — |
| Closure Style | Buckle | — |
| Style | Casual | — |
| Type | Mary Janes | — |
| Breathable | Yes | — |
| Season | Summer | — |
| Lining Material | Leather | — |
| Support Type | Cushioning | — |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for everyday wear?
- The Polley. Its black leather and slip-resistant rubber sole suit daily wear, and it is easier to clean than hair-on leopard leather.
- Which lasts longer?
- Both are Goodyear welted, so both can be resoled. The Polley's rubber sole resists oil and abrasion better; the Elphie II's hair-on upper is the more fragile part.
- Is the Elphie II worth the extra?
- Only if you want the leopard print. It costs more to maintain and its PVC sole is less grippy than the Polley's rubber sole.
- Can I wear the Polley in rain?
- Yes, the rubber Airwair sole is slip-resistant. The smooth leather upper handles damp weather better than hair-on leather.
- How do I clean the Elphie II?
- Brush gently with a soft hair brush only. Do not polish or condition the hair-on leather.
- Which is lighter?
- The Polley is listed at 1 lb 7.1 oz per shoe. Dr. Martens does not publish a weight for the Elphie II.