Dr. Scholl's Curved Heel Buffer vs Scholl Callus Hard Skin File

Both are manual double-sided foot files from the same parent brand, so the choice comes down to shape and use. The Dr. Scholl's Curved Heel Buffer is the better pick for most people: its curved body follows the heel and its non-slip handle stays controllable wet or dry, and it holds a 4.6 out of 5 from 234 ratings. The Scholl Callus Hard Skin File is a slimmer, lighter tool with a distinctive shape for reaching awkward contours, but it is dry-use only and its metal heads can loosen if dropped.

• Choose the Dr. Scholl's Curved Heel Buffer if you want one tool for heels and calluses that works in the shower as well as on dry skin, with a grip that holds when wet.
• Choose the Scholl Callus Hard Skin File if you file dry skin only and want a light, compact file shaped to reach curved edges and tight contours.