Dr. Scholl's Curved Heel Buffer vs NYK1 MegaFile Foot File

Both are manual foot files that work wet or dry, so the choice comes down to shape and surface. The Dr. Scholl's Curved Heel Buffer has a curved, double-sided coarse file with a non-slip handle that follows the heel and gives you a gentler smoothing side. The NYK1 MegaFile uses a large stainless steel micro-blade plate with perforated grooves that takes off hard skin faster and has far more owner feedback behind it. Pick Dr. Scholl's for controlled, gradual smoothing and a shape that hugs the foot; pick NYK1 for speed on thick calluses and a bigger working surface.

• Choose the Dr. Scholl's Curved Heel Buffer if you want a curved, double-sided file with a coarse side and a gentler side for controlled smoothing around the heel and edges.
• Choose the NYK1 MegaFile if you have thick, hardened calluses and want a large stainless steel blade plate that removes skin fast.