Dr. Scholl's Callus Remover Foot File vs NYK1 MegaFile Foot File

Both are manual foot files that work on wet or dry skin, but they are built differently. The NYK1 MegaFile uses a large perforated stainless steel plate with a non-slip rubber grip and has far more owner feedback, with 4.7 from over 1,000 ratings against 4.4 from 370 for the Dr. Scholl's. The Dr. Scholl's is the more compact, medicated option with a debris catcher and an ergonomic handle, which suits people who want less mess and a smaller tool. For heavy calluses and cracked heels, most shoppers will get faster results from the NYK1.

• Choose the Dr. Scholl's if you want a smaller medicated file with a debris catcher and a comfortable handle for quick touch-ups.
• Choose the NYK1 MegaFile if you have thick calluses or cracked heels and want a large, fast-cutting stainless steel plate with a strong owner track record.