Drolet Columbia II Wood Stove vs Ashley AW2520E-P Wood Stove

The Ashley AW2520E-P is the bigger heater: a 2.73 cu ft firebox, 21-inch logs and up to 112,800 BTU for spaces up to 2,500 sq ft. The Drolet Columbia II tops out at 65,000 BTU and 1,800 sq ft, but it is a simpler, lighter stove with a strong 4.5-star record across 66 ratings. Pick the Drolet for a tight, well-insulated room or a mobile home where you want easy loading and modest output; pick the Ashley for an open plan or cold climate where you need raw heat and long logs.

• Choose the Drolet Columbia II if your space is around 1,800 sq ft or less and you want a proven, well-rated stove that is easier to handle and install.
• Choose the Ashley AW2520E-P if you are heating a large or open area up to 2,500 sq ft and want a big firebox that takes 21-inch logs.