Drolet Columbia II Wood Stove vs Ashley Hearth AW1120E-P Wood Stove

The Drolet Columbia II is the better stove for most people: it heats up to 1,800 sq ft, is certified for mobile homes and alcoves, and its 4.5-star owner record is solid. The Ashley Hearth AW1120E-P is a simpler pedestal stove rated for 1,200 sq ft, with a cast iron door, airwashed glass and an ash pan that make daily use easier. Pick the Drolet for a larger house or a mobile home; pick the Ashley for a cabin or open room where the look and ash cleanup matter more than raw coverage.

• Choose the Drolet Columbia II if you need to heat a larger space, plan to install in a mobile home or alcove, or want the longer track record of owner ratings.
• Choose the Ashley Hearth AW1120E-P if you are heating a cabin or single open room and want a cast iron door, airwashed glass and an ash pan for easier cleanout.