Duck Max Strength Poly Bubble Mailer #5 vs Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer

Buy the Duck Max Strength mailer if you ship fragile or bulky items and want water resistance and a gusset that expands to swallow odd shapes. Buy the Scotch Curbside Recyclable mailer if recycling matters to you and you ship flat or lightly padded goods. The Duck is a tougher, more protective mailer with far stronger owner ratings; the Scotch is paper-based and curbside recyclable but has no water barrier and a thinner cushion.

• Choose the Duck Max Strength mailer if you need a water-resistant, tear-resistant padded mailer that expands to fit bulky or irregular items without a box.
• Choose the Scotch Curbside Recyclable mailer if you want a paper-based padded mailer that goes straight into curbside recycling and you ship mostly flat or lightly cushioned goods.