StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Pen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-Count vs Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer

Buy the Pen+Gear five-pack if you send a handful of items a month and want a small, simple pack. Buy the Scotch case if you ship regularly and want mailers that go in the curbside recycling bin. Owners rate the Pen+Gear higher (4.9 from 22 ratings vs 4.1 from 27), but the Scotch is the better fit for steady volume. Both are Kraft paper with self-stick seals and similar padding.

  • Choose the Pen+Gear if you mail occasionally and want a small pack of padded mailers that seals without tape.
  • Choose the Scotch if you ship in volume and want curbside-recyclable mailers in a large case.

Prices

  • Pen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-Count: $5.72 at Walmart (last seen Nov 10)
  • Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer: $2.49 at Hy-Vee (last seen Nov 10)
  • Difference: the Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer is $3.23 cheaper than the Pen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-Count at the latest prices (Nov 10)
Pen+Gear
Pen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-Count

Pen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-Count

4.9(22 ratings)
$5.72at WalmartChecked Nov 10
See all prices and details
Visit Walmart
Pros
  • Small pack suits occasional shipping
  • High owner rating
  • Self-stick seal needs no tape
  • Water-resistant paper construction
Cons
  • Only five mailers per pack
  • No curbside recycling claim
  • No recycled content stated
Scotch
Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer

Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer

4.1(27 ratings)
$2.49at Hy-VeeChecked Nov 10
See all prices and details
Visit Hy-Vee
Pros
  • Case of 100 covers steady shipping
  • Curbside recyclable
  • Standard size 5 dimensions
  • Self-adhesive closure
Cons
  • Lower owner rating
  • 0% recycled content
  • Large case is overkill for light use

What separates them

Pen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-CountScotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer
Pack size5 mailers per packCase of 100
RecyclabilityPaper and corrugated, water-resistant; no curbside claimMarked curbside recyclable
Size10.5 x 15 in10.5 x 14.7 in (size 5)
ClosurePeel-and-stick self sealSelf-adhesive strip
Owner ratings4.9 out of 5 from 22 ratings4.1 out of 5 from 27 ratings
Recycled contentNot stated0% recycled material
Best forHome, office and occasional sellersBusinesses shipping in bulk

Price history

  • Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer: lowest $2.49 on Nov 10 at Hy-Vee.

Prices at every store

Pen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-Count

  • WalmartNew

    In stock

    $5.72Checked Nov 10
    Visit Walmart
Prices and history →

Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer

  • Hy-VeeNew

    In stock

    $2.49Checked Nov 10
    Visit Hy-Vee
  • TargetNew

    In stock

    $2.59+ $10.99 shippingChecked Nov 10
    Visit Target
  • Thorp ControlsNew

    Availability unknown

    $3.45Checked Nov 3
    Visit Thorp Controls
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownSold by achan0305

    $5.00Checked Nov 10
    Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 8 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecPen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-CountScotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer
colorOtherNatural Kraft
size10.5" x 15"Size 5
MaterialKraftPaper-based, Kraft Paper
multipack_quantity1—
SealSelf Stick—
Overall Length (Imperial)—10.5 in
Quantity—100
Type—Padded Mailer
Height—11.25
Width—15.0 in (carton pack)
Length—12
Security Tint—No
Show all 21 specsShow fewer specs
SpecPen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-CountScotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer
Closure Type—Self-Adhesive
Recycled Material %—0%
Suitable Contents—variety of items
Application—packaging
Typical Users—businesses
Packaging Type—Case of 100
Recycled Content—Curbside recyclable
Sustainability Certifications—Curbside recyclable
Shape—Square

What reviewers say

Pen+Gear Padded Paper Mailers, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft, 5-Count

  • 4.9 / 522 ratings

Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 22 ratings, buyers are largely satisfied with these mailers. They like the easy peel-and-stick sealing and the padding for small shipments.

What people mention
  • SealingPraisedBuyers like that the peel-and-stick strip closes each mailer quickly without tape.
  • PaddingPraisedThe fluted corrugate gives enough cushioning for small, light items.
  • BuildPraisedThe Kraft paper feels sturdy for everyday mailing.

Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer

  • 4.1 / 527 ratings

Buyers rate it 4.1 out of 5 from 27 ratings. Most like that it is genuinely curbside recyclable and seals quickly, while some find the padding thin for fragile goods.

What people mention
  • RecyclabilityPraisedBuyers value that the whole mailer goes in curbside recycling instead of being split from bubble wrap.
  • PaddingMixedThe paper padding protects light items but is thin for anything fragile.
  • ClosurePraisedThe self-adhesive strip seals fast and holds without extra tape.
  • SizeMixed

Questions and answers

Which is better for a small online seller?
The Scotch case if you ship several items a week, since 100 mailers keep you stocked. The Pen+Gear five-pack is enough for occasional sales.
Are the Scotch mailers really curbside recyclable?
Scotch labels them curbside recyclable, and the paper-based Kraft construction supports that. Check your local program's rules for padded mailers.
Which size fits a book or small box?
Both are size 5, about 10.5 in wide. The Pen+Gear is 15 in long and the Scotch 14.7 in, so either fits a paperback or small box with padding.
Which do owners rate higher?
The Pen+Gear, at 4.9 from 22 ratings against 4.1 from 27 for the Scotch. The Scotch sample is slightly larger, so treat the gap as a lean, not a verdict.
Is the Scotch worth stepping up to?
Yes if volume and recycling matter to you. The Pen+Gear makes more sense for light use, where a 100-count case would sit unused.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer vs Kraft Bubble Mailers — Padded Shipping Envelopes in Multiple Colors
  • Poly Bubble Mailers — Padded Shipping Envelopes in All Sizes & Colors vs Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer
  • Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer vs Mailing Envelopes 100 Pack Silver Metallic Bubble Wrap Lined Padded Mailer Self Seal Foil Bulk
  • Pen+Gear Padded Paper Mailer, #5 (10.5 in. x 15 in.), Kraft vs Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer
  • Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer vs Staples EasyClose Poly Bubble Mailers 10-1/2" x 15" #5 8/Pack (51629) 657391
  • Fosmon Kraft Bubble Mailer vs Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer
  • Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer vs Temu Padded Bubble Mailers
  • Duck Max Strength Self-Sealing Gusseted Poly Bubble Mailer #5, 10.5"x 15", Solid Print vs Scotch Curbside Recyclable Padded Mailer

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best 10.5 x 14 padded mailers in bulk
  • Best 10.5 x 14 padded shipping envelopes
Size 5 fits small items only, so larger orders need a different size.