StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug vs CAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3

These are not really rivals: the Earth Weave Catskill is a plush, chemical-free wool rug for a living room or bedroom, and the CAMILSON Herringbone is a thin, washable-look utility mat for doorways, kitchens and patios. Buy the Catskill if you want softness underfoot and no synthetic backing, and accept that wool sheds and pills in high-traffic spots. Buy the CAMILSON if you need a small, easy-to-clean mat and don't mind a flat, synthetic jute-look surface. On build, the Catskill is the more substantial product; on convenience, the CAMILSON wins.

  • Choose the Earth Weave Catskill if you want a soft, 100% wool rug with no VOCs, latex or stain coatings, and you have a room where shedding can be tolerated.
  • Choose the CAMILSON Herringbone if you need a small, thin, easy-to-clean mat for a doorway, kitchen, patio or rental, and softness underfoot is not the priority.

Prices

  • Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug: $489.00 at Gimme the Good Stuff (checked today)
  • CAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3: $15.92 at Walmart (checked today)
  • Difference: the CAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3 is $473.08 cheaper than the Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug today
Earth Weave
Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug

Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug

5(2 ratings)
$489.00at Gimme the Good StuffChecked 2 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Gimme the Good Stuff
Pros
  • Soft, plush wool underfoot even without a thick pad
  • No VOCs, synthetic latex, mothproofing or stain coatings
  • Wide size range up to 10'x12'
  • Colors reported to match the photos
  • Serged wool edges
Cons
  • Pills and sheds where feet rub
  • Wool needs careful spot cleaning
  • Minimum order of 13 square yards limits small purchases
  • Not suitable for wet or outdoor areas
CAMILSON
CAMILSON Herringbone Non Shedding Easy-Cleaning Indoor Outdoor Easy Jute Rug Bone 2x3

CAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3

CAMILSON Herringbone Non Shedding Easy-Cleaning Indoor Outdoor Easy Jute Rug Bone 2x3

4.4(576 ratings)
$15.92at WalmartChecked 2 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Walmart
Pros
  • Thin and light, easy to move and clean
  • Non-shedding face
  • Works indoors and outdoors
  • Neutral herringbone pattern suits many rooms
  • Small size fits doorways and tight spots
Cons
  • Only 2'x3' in this listing
  • Flat synthetic jute look, not soft wool
  • Not marketed as free of chemicals
  • Little cushioning; a pad may be needed

What separates them

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area RugCAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3
Material100% virgin wool, organically dyed, with hemp/cotton and jute backingsSynthetic jute-look fiber with a flat woven face
Pile and feelVariable cut-pile, 65 oz wool weight, plush underfootLight and thin, flat underfoot
Size range4'x6' up to 10'x12', plus roll goods2'x3' only in this listing
Indoor/outdoor useResidential and light commercial indoorsMarketed for patios, decks, pool sides and garages as well as indoors
CleaningSpot clean; wool needs care and can pill and shedEasy-cleaning, non-shedding, thin enough to hose or wipe
Chemical contentNo VOCs, synthetic latex, mothproofing, flame retardants or stain coatingsNot marketed as chemical-free
Durability in trafficWool wears well but pills where feet rub, such as under a deskHolds up to wet and dirty areas but is a light mat, not a room rug
OriginMade in the US from European woolImported; origin not stated

Price history

  • CAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3: lowest $23.92 on Nov 19 at Amazon.

Prices at every store

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug

  • Gimme the Good StuffNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $489.00Checked 2 h ago
    Visit Gimme the Good Stuff
Prices and history →

CAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3

  • WalmartNew

    In stockSold by CAMILSONReturns: Sold by a Walmart Marketplace seller; returns go to the seller under the seller's returns policy.

    $15.92Checked 2 h ago
    Visit Walmart
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $23.92Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecEarth Weave Catskill Wool Area RugCAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3
Face fiber100% Wool, Organically Dyed—
Wool weight65oz—
Primary backingHemp/Cotton—
ConstructionVariable Cut-Pile—
Available sizes4'x6', 6'x9', 8'x10' and 10'x12'—
Secondary backingjute—
Roll width13' 2"—
DurabilityAll residential applications & light commercial—
Color optionsHeron, Palomino, Otter, Brindle, Barred Owl & S…—
Country of manufactureUS—
Full roll132 square yards—
color—Off-White
Show all 14 specsShow fewer specs
SpecEarth Weave Catskill Wool Area RugCAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3
size—2' x 3'
actual_color—Herringbone-Bone

What reviewers say

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug

Owners describe the Catskill as soft and plush underfoot even without a thick pad, with color matching the swatches and only a faint wool smell out of the roll. The main complaint is pilling and shedding where feet rest, such as under a desk.

What people mention
  • SoftnessPraisedOwners say the cut pile feels plush underfoot even without a thick rug pad.
  • ColorPraisedBuyers report the color arrives as pictured.
  • SmellPraisedOwners notice only a faint wool smell when the rug is unrolled.
  • SheddingCriticisedReviewers report pilling and shedding where feet go, such as under a desk.

CAMILSON Herringbone Jute Rug Bone 2x3

  • 4.4 / 5576 ratings

Rated 4.4 out of 5 across 576 ratings. Buyers generally like the look and the low, flat profile. Some find it thinner than expected and note the light color needs attention.

What people mention
  • ThicknessMixedSome buyers find it thinner than they expected, while others like the low profile.
  • CleaningPraisedOwners say it is easy to clean and shake out.
  • ColorMixedThe bone tone is liked for its neutral look but shows dirt readily.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a living room?
The Earth Weave Catskill. It is a plush wool rug in room sizes, while the CAMILSON is a thin 2'x3' mat meant for doorways and utility areas.
Which lasts longer?
Wool generally outlasts a thin synthetic mat in a dry interior, but the Catskill pills and sheds in high-traffic spots. The CAMILSON is durable for wet, dirty areas but is a light mat, not a room rug.
Is the Catskill worth stepping up to?
Yes if you want softness, no synthetic backing and a large size. No if you need something you can wipe clean or put outdoors.
Can the CAMILSON go outside?
Yes. It is marketed for patios, decks, pool sides and garages as well as indoors. The Catskill is for indoor residential and light commercial use.
Does the wool rug shed?
Owners report some pilling and shedding where feet rub, such as under a desk. A faint wool smell is also reported, which fades.
Is the CAMILSON safe for a kid's room?
It is marketed for kids' rooms and is easy to clean, but it is not advertised as free of chemicals. The Catskill makes the stronger no-VOC claim.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug vs SAFAVIEH Natural Fiber Sisal Area Rug 8'x10' Marble & Beige
  • CHITOOMA 8'x10' Boho Area Rugs for Living Room, Machine Washable Area Rug with Non-Slip Backing, Stain Resistant Non-Shed Carpet for Bedroom, Dining Room, Dorm, Office vs Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug
  • CHITOOMA 8'x10' Boho Area Rugs for Living Room, Machine Washable Area Rug with Non-Slip Backing, Stain Resistant Non-Shed Carpet for Bedroom, Dining Room, Dorm, Office vs CAMILSON Herringbone Non Shedding Easy-Cleaning Indoor Outdoor Easy Jute Rug Bone 2x3
  • Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug vs Jute Cotton Area Rug 5X8 ft Natural Hand Woven Farmhouse Rug Large
  • Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug vs Ruggable Washable Rug (Standard, various collections)
  • SAFAVIEH Natural Fiber Sisal Area Rug 8'x10' Marble & Beige vs CAMILSON Herringbone Non Shedding Easy-Cleaning Indoor Outdoor Easy Jute Rug Bone 2x3

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best non-toxic area rugs
  • SheddingPraisedBuyers report the weave does not shed.