StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug vs Ruggable Washable Rug

The Earth Weave Catskill is the better rug: dense 65 oz wool, natural hemp, cotton and jute backing, no chemical treatments, and it holds up in light commercial use. The Ruggable is the practical pick for homes with pets, kids or spills, because the cover comes off and goes in the washing machine. Owners of the Catskill report soft, plush pile and accurate color, with some pilling and shedding where feet rub. The Ruggable is flatter underfoot and its chenille cover feels thinner than wool.

  • Choose the Earth Weave Catskill if you want a durable natural-fiber rug with no VOCs, no synthetic latex and no stain or flame treatments, and you can live without machine washing.
  • Choose the Ruggable if you need a rug you can pull up and wash after spills, pet accidents or muddy feet, and you prefer a low, flat pile.

Prices

  • Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug: $489.00 at Gimme the Good Stuff (last seen Nov 12)
  • Ruggable Washable Rug: $169.00 at Ruggable (last seen Nov 12)
  • Difference: the Ruggable Washable Rug is $320.00 cheaper than the Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug at the latest prices (Nov 12)
Earth Weave
Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug

Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug

5(2 ratings)
$489.00at Gimme the Good StuffChecked Nov 12
See all prices and details
Visit Gimme the Good Stuff
Pros
  • Dense 65 oz wool feels plush even without a pad
  • No VOCs, synthetic latex, glues or chemical treatments
  • Natural hemp, cotton and jute backing
  • Rated for light commercial use
  • Serged wool edges for a clean finish
Cons
  • Cannot be machine washed
  • Pilling and shedding reported where feet rub
  • Limited color range
  • Some sizes ship as cut yardage with a minimum order
Ruggable
Ruggable Washable Rug (Standard, various collections)

Ruggable Washable Rug

Ruggable Washable Rug (Standard, various collections)

$169.00at RuggableChecked Nov 12
See all prices and details
Visit Ruggable
Pros
  • Cover comes off and goes in the washing machine
  • Stain-resistant surface handles spills
  • Low profile works under doors and furniture
  • Wide range of patterns and sizes
Cons
  • Chenille is synthetic and thinner underfoot
  • Two-piece system can shift or wrinkle at the edges
  • Not rated for commercial use
  • Patterns may fade with repeated washing

What separates them

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area RugRuggable Washable Rug
Fiber100% virgin wool, organically dyedChenille, a synthetic fiber
BackingHemp and cotton bonded with natural rubber, jute secondary backingTwo-piece system with a separate gripper pad
WashingSpot clean and professional cleaning onlyCover is machine washable
PileVariable cut pile, 65 oz, plush underfootFlat woven, low profile
Stain resistanceNo stain-resistant coating; wool resists soil naturallyTreated stain-resistant surface
Chemical contentNo VOCs, mothproofing, flame retardants or synthetic latexSynthetic construction with treatments
Durability ratingRated for all residential use and light commercialDesigned for residential indoor use
SheddingSome pilling and shedding reported in high-traffic spotsLittle shedding; edges can lift over time

Price history

  • Ruggable Washable Rug: lowest $169.00 on Nov 12 at Ruggable.

Prices at every store

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug

  • Gimme the Good StuffNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $489.00Checked Nov 12
    Visit Gimme the Good Stuff
Prices and history →

Ruggable Washable Rug

  • RuggableNew

    In stock

    $169.00Free shippingChecked Nov 12
    Visit Ruggable
  • eBayNew

    In stock

    $179.95Free shippingChecked Nov 12
    Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecEarth Weave Catskill Wool Area RugRuggable Washable Rug
ConstructionVariable Cut-PileFlat Woven
Face fiber100% Wool, Organically Dyed—
Wool weight65oz—
Primary backingHemp/Cotton—
Available sizes4'x6', 6'x9', 8'x10' and 10'x12'—
Secondary backingjute—
Roll width13' 2"—
DurabilityAll residential applications & light commercial—
Color optionsHeron, Palomino, Otter, Brindle, Barred Owl & S…—
Country of manufactureUS—
Full roll132 square yards—
Shape—Rectangular
Show all 20 specsShow fewer specs
SpecEarth Weave Catskill Wool Area RugRuggable Washable Rug
Washable—Yes
Color—Blue
Pattern—Medallion, Floral, Shape
Material—Chenille
Easy Care—Yes
Stain-Resistant—Yes
Placement—Indoor
Rug Size—6 ft, 8 ft

What reviewers say

Earth Weave Catskill Wool Area Rug

Owners describe the Catskill as soft and plush underfoot even without a thick pad, with color matching the swatches and only a faint wool smell out of the roll. The main complaint is pilling and shedding where feet rest, such as under a desk.

What people mention
  • SoftnessPraisedOwners say the cut pile feels plush underfoot even without a thick rug pad.
  • ColorPraisedBuyers report the color arrives as pictured.
  • SmellPraisedOwners notice only a faint wool smell when the rug is unrolled.
  • SheddingCriticisedReviewers report pilling and shedding where feet go, such as under a desk.

Ruggable Washable Rug

Owners value being able to wash a large rug and report that stains come out. Many find it thinner and less cushioned than a conventional rug, and some mention edges curling or the cover needing smoothing after a wash.

What people mention
  • WashabilityPraisedOwners say the cover goes through the washing machine and comes out clean.
  • CushioningCriticisedMany find it thin and firm compared with a plush tufted rug.
  • Stain resistancePraisedSpills and pet accidents are reported to wipe up or wash out.
  • Edge curlingMixedSome say edges curl or the cover wrinkles after washing and need smoothing.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a house with pets and kids?
The Ruggable. Its cover is machine washable and the surface is stain-resistant, so accidents and spills are easy to fix. The Catskill handles soil well but needs spot cleaning and professional cleaning for deep stains.
Which lasts longer?
The Catskill. Dense wool over a hemp, cotton and jute backing is built for years of residential use and is rated for light commercial traffic. The Ruggable's chenille cover wears faster with repeated washing.
Is the Catskill safe for a nursery or chemically sensitive person?
Yes. It has no VOCs, synthetic latex, mothproofing agents, flame retardants or stain coatings, and it is often recommended for babies and sensitive people. Air it out briefly; owners report only a faint wool smell.
Is the Ruggable worth stepping up to a larger size?
Yes if the rug anchors a seating area. A larger cover keeps chairs on the rug and reduces edge curling, which is the most common complaint about the two-piece system.
Does the Catskill need a rug pad?
Not for comfort. Owners say the pile feels soft without one. A pad still helps with grip on hard floors and reduces sliding.
Can the Ruggable go in a high-traffic hallway?
It can, but the flat chenille shows wear sooner than wool. For hallways and entries with heavy foot traffic, the Catskill's wool pile holds up better.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug vs SAFAVIEH Natural Fiber Sisal Area Rug 8'x10' Marble & Beige
  • Earth Weave Catskill Natural Wool Area Rug vs Jute Cotton Area Rug 5X8 ft Natural Hand Woven Farmhouse Rug Large
  • Ruggable Washable Rug (Standard, various collections) vs Jute Cotton Area Rug 5X8 ft Natural Hand Woven Farmhouse Rug Large
  • SAFAVIEH Natural Fiber Sisal Area Rug 8'x10' Marble & Beige vs Ruggable Washable Rug (Standard, various collections)

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best non-toxic area rugs