Eastland Sea Dog Boat Shoe vs Eastland Scarborough Water Resistant Loafer

Both are Eastland leather slip-ons with moc toes and rubber soles, but they serve different feet. The Sea Dog is a true boat shoe: handsewn moccasin construction, a 360-degree rawhide lace that lets you cinch the fit, rust-proof eyelets and a leather-lined molded EVA insole. The Scarborough is a plainer water-resistant loafer with a memory foam insole and a 1-inch heel, and it skips laces entirely. Owners of the Sea Dog call it comfortable out of the box and well made, though sizing complaints run both ways, so try it on or check the size chart. Pick the Sea Dog for wet-deck grip and an adjustable fit; pick the Scarborough for easy on-off and a softer footbed.

• Choose the Eastland Sea Dog if you want an adjustable lace-up boat shoe with handsewn construction and better grip on wet surfaces.
• Choose the Eastland Scarborough if you want a slip-on loafer with a memory foam insole and a water-resistant upper for everyday wear.