Which is better for rainy weather?

The Scarborough. Its upper is water resistant, while the Patricia is not described as water resistant at all.

Which is more comfortable for long walks?

The Scarborough, thanks to its memory foam insole and 1 in heel. The Patricia is a thin flat with a 0.25 in heel and less cushioning.

Is the Scarborough worth $18.50 more?

If you walk in wet weather or stand for long periods, yes. If you want a light, dressy flat for dry days, the Patricia at $31.50 at eBay is the better value.

The Patricia. Reviewers say its fit runs wide, and it comes in wide widths. The Scarborough is listed in standard widths only.

Both use rubber outsoles and leather or suede uppers. The Scarborough's heavier build and fabric lining suggest more durability for daily wear, but neither brand publishes a lifespan figure.

Do both come in large sizes?

The Patricia does, from US 4 to 15.5 with half sizes. The Scarborough's listed range is narrower, so check your size before buying.

Eastland Patricia Moc Loafer vs Eastland Scarborough Water Resistant Loafer

Both are Eastland moc-toe slip-on loafers, but they suit different feet and budgets. The Patricia is the cheaper, lighter, dressier pick at $31.50 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, versus $50.00 at Macy's for the Scarborough. Buy the Scarborough if you want water resistance and a memory foam insole for wet-weather wear; buy the Patricia if you want a soft suede or leather flat at the lowest price.

Today the Eastland Scarborough Water Resistant Loafer costs $15.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.