Eastland Wellington Leather Sneaker vs Eastland Patricia Moc Loafer

These are different shoes for different jobs, so the choice comes down to how you dress. The Wellington is a lace-up leather high-top with a padded collar and EVA insole, built for walking and casual wear with jeans. The Patricia is a slip-on suede and leather moc loafer with a low platform and foam insole, aimed at women who want a comfortable driving or casual shoe. Owners of the Patricia call it soft, well made and flattering, though several say the colors differ from the photos and the fit runs wide. The Wellington has fewer owner reports to go on, so judge it on the leather upper and rubber sole rather than on feedback.

• Choose the Wellington if you want a lace-up leather high-top for everyday walking and a more secure fit.
• Choose the Patricia if you want a slip-on suede loafer for driving and casual wear and prefer a low platform.