Which is better for a queen bed?

The Eddie Bauer Edgewood. It comes in Queen; the Woolrich set is listed in Twin only.

Which has better ratings?

The Eddie Bauer, at 4.5 out of 5 from 6,700 ratings versus 4.0 from 1,800 for the Woolrich.

Will the Woolrich fit a thick mattress?

It is listed for mattresses up to 12 inches deep. The Eddie Bauer set does not state a depth.

Are both cotton flannel?

Yes. Both sets are cotton flannel, so warmth and hand feel should be similar.

Is the Eddie Bauer worth more money?

No prices were given, so check current store prices. The Eddie Bauer adds sizes, colors and a higher rating; the Woolrich adds a stated depth.

Eddie Bauer Edgewood Plaid Flannel Sheet Set vs Woolrich Cotton Flannel Sheet Set

Buy the Eddie Bauer Edgewood if you want a plaid flannel set in more sizes and colors, or if ratings matter to you: 4.5 from 6,700 ratings versus 4.0 from 1,800. Buy the Woolrich if you need a Twin set with a stated 12-inch pocket depth and plaid is all you want. Prices were not provided for either set, so compare live store prices before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.