Which is better for a Queen bed?

The Printed Cotton Flannel Sheet Set. It comes in Queen; the Rookeries is sold in Full/Double only.

The Rookeries. Its material is listed as cotton flannel, while the Printed set lists cotton, polyester and flannel.

Is the Rookeries worth the extra?

Only if you have a Full bed and want pure cotton. Its recent low, $28.07, is 34 cents above the Printed set's $27.73, but its recent high, $36.95, is well above $31.10.

Which fits a thicker mattress?

The Rookeries states a 14-inch maximum mattress depth. The Printed set says deep pocket but gives no depth figure.

Which has better ratings?

They tie at 4.6 out of 5. The Rookeries has more ratings, 5,100 versus 3,900.

Neither listing gives a warranty or fabric weight, so there is no basis to say. Cotton flannel tends to pill with washing; the Rookeries' all-cotton content avoids polyester but does not guarantee durability.

Eddie Bauer Printed Cotton Flannel Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Rookeries Flannel Sheet Set

Both are Eddie Bauer cotton flannel sheet sets at nearly the same price, so the choice comes down to size and fabric. The Printed Cotton Flannel comes in Twin through King and blends in polyester; the Rookeries is Full/Double only, all cotton, 150 thread count, with a 14-inch pocket. Latest prices are close: the Printed set ran $27.73 to $31.10 since November 2, 2026, and the Rookeries $28.07 to $36.95. Buy the Printed set for any size other than Full or for the lowest price; buy the Rookeries for a Full bed if you want pure cotton flannel.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.