Which is better for cold weather?

The Eddie Bauer flannel set. Its brushed flannel traps warmth, while the Hotel Collection Supima percale is crisp and breathable for hot sleepers.

Which fits a thick mattress?

The Hotel Collection sheet fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. The Eddie Bauer set tops out at 14 inches.

Is the Hotel Collection sheet worth the extra money?

Only if you want one high thread count Supima cotton sheet that fits a deep mattress. The Eddie Bauer set gives you four pieces for less.

Both are machine washable. Buyers of the Hotel Collection sheet report durable fabric but also some pilling; flannel tends to pill with wear, so wash both gently.

Does the Hotel Collection come as a full set?

No. The listing is for a fitted sheet only. The Eddie Bauer set includes fitted sheet, flat sheet and two pillowcases.

The Hotel Collection Supima percale. Flannel is warmer, so pick it for winter or cool rooms.

Eddie Bauer School of Fish Flannel Sheet Set vs Hotel Collection 680 Thread Count 100% Supima Cotton Fitted Sheet

Buy the Eddie Bauer School of Fish Flannel Sheet Set if you want a full 4-piece set, a warm flannel feel and the lowest price: it was $40.24 on November 2 and has ranged up to $48.39. Buy the Hotel Collection 680 Supima Fitted Sheet if you want a single crisp, breathable Supima cotton fitted sheet that fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep; it is $56.00 at Macy's as of November 7. The flannel set costs less and covers the whole bed, while the Hotel Collection sheet costs more for one piece but uses finer cotton.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.