Which is better for a deep mattress?

The Liz Claiborne set fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. The Eddie Bauer flannel set fits up to 14 inches. If your mattress is 15 inches or deeper, choose the Liz Claiborne.

Which set lasts longer?

The Eddie Bauer set has the stronger record, with 4.6 out of 5 from 5,300 ratings and no pilling complaints noted. Liz Claiborne reviewers report pilling after a few washes.

Is the Eddie Bauer set worth the extra?

There is little extra to pay. The Eddie Bauer set has been as low as $40.24 since November 2, 2026, and the Liz Claiborne set is $41.99 at JCPenney as of November 7, 2026.

The Eddie Bauer flannel has a peached finish and is described as soft and breathable. The Liz Claiborne sateen is smooth rather than fluffy. Pick flannel for coziness, sateen for a cool, smooth feel.

Does the Liz Claiborne set really resist wrinkles?

It is marketed as wrinkle resistant, but reviewers report heavy wrinkling. The Eddie Bauer flannel makes no wrinkle claim.

Which is better for warm sleepers?

The Liz Claiborne sateen weave is the cooler choice. Flannel traps more warmth, so the Eddie Bauer set suits cold rooms better.

Liz Claiborne Luxury Performance 1000tc Sheets vs Eddie Bauer School of Fish Flannel Sheet Set

Buy the Eddie Bauer School of Fish Flannel set if you want a soft, breathable flannel that holds up and fits a mattress up to 14 inches deep. Buy the Liz Claiborne Luxury Performance 1000tc set only if you need an 18-inch deep pocket and want a smooth sateen look at a low price. The Eddie Bauer set has been as low as $40.24 since November 2, 2026, while the Liz Claiborne set is $41.99 at JCPenney as of November 7, 2026. The Eddie Bauer set carries a 4.6 rating from 5,300 ratings against 3.8 from 628 for the Liz Claiborne.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.