Coop Home Goods Eden Adjustable Pillow vs Beddy's Adjustable Comfort Pillow

Buy the Coop Eden if you want a proven adjustable pillow with a long track record and a 5-year warranty. Its shredded gel-foam and microfiber fill lets you add or remove loft freely, and 3,475 ratings at 4.8 out of 5 back it up. The Adjustable Comfort Pillow uses three stacked foam slabs instead of loose fill, so it feels more like a layered foam pillow than a fluffable one. It suits sleepers who want firm, medium and low inserts to swap, but its 152 ratings and 3-year warranty are a shorter record.

• Choose the Coop Eden Adjustable Pillow if you want loose, reshapable fill, a cooling bamboo-derived cover and the longest warranty of the two.
• Choose the Adjustable Comfort Pillow if you prefer swapping firm, medium and low foam inserts over adding or removing loose fill.