Which is better for a small apartment?

The 4.5 ft tree. It is about 1.9 ft wide and 4.5 ft tall, so it fits a narrow corner where the 6 ft edx tree would crowd the room.

The edx 6 ft tree, with 571 tips against 226 on the 4.5 ft tree. More tips per foot of height means fewer bare gaps.

Is the 4.5 ft tree worth the extra $2.50?

Only if you need the smaller footprint or want the UL588-certified transformer. Otherwise the edx tree gives more height, tips and lights for less.

Which is safer around children and pets?

The 4.5 ft tree lists a UL588 certified transformer. The edx tree lists flame-retardant PVC but no lighting certification, so the 4.5 ft tree has the clearer safety claim.

How long will each last?

Neither maker states a lifespan. Both use PVC branches and metal stands; the 4.5 ft tree says its PVC resists deformation, and the edx tree says its base is thickened and foldable.

Can I use either outdoors?

No. Both are plug-in indoor trees. The edx tree lists home, office and party use, and the 4.5 ft tree lists floor placement indoors.

edx 6ft Pre-lit Pencil Christmas Tree vs 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Pencil Christmas Tree

Buy the edx 6 ft if you want a taller tree for a living room or office lobby and want to spend the least; it is $37.99 at Walmart as of November 5, 2026. Buy the 4.5 ft Pre-Lit Premium Hinged Fir if you need a compact tree for a small apartment or narrow corner and want a UL588-certified transformer; it is $40.49 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026. The two prices are within about $2.50 of each other, so height and light count should decide it, not cost.

Today the edx 6ft Pre-lit Pencil Christmas Tree costs $2.50 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.