Elf Stor Premium Christmas Tree Bag vs HOMEYA Upright Christmas Tree Storage Bag

Buy the Elf Stor if you take the tree apart and want a flat, zippered bag that slides onto a closet shelf. Buy the HOMEYA if you keep the tree assembled and want to wheel it into the garage upright, decorations still on. The Elf Stor is a simple nylon bag with vinyl handles and a label tag; the HOMEYA is heavier 210D Oxford cloth with a water-resistant PU liner, a full-length zipper, buckle straps and a bottom cinch. Owners rate the Elf Stor well for the job it does, but it offers no structure and no water protection, while the HOMEYA's upright shape and coating suit damp garages and attics better.

• Choose the Elf Stor if you disassemble your tree each year and want a long, flat bag that lies on a shelf or under a bed.
• Choose the HOMEYA if you store your tree assembled, decorations on, and need an upright cover that stands in a garage or attic.