Elf Stor Premium Christmas Tree Bag vs TreeKeeper Upright Christmas Tree Storage Bag

Buy the TreeKeeper upright bag if you want to store your tree assembled and upright, which cuts setup and takedown time and saves floor space. The Elf Stor is a flat horizontal bag: simpler, cheaper-feeling and easier to carry by its handles, but you must disassemble the tree first. Owners rate the TreeKeeper higher (4.8 from 726 ratings versus 4.6 from 52), and its polyester fabric and dolly make it the sturdier long-term pick for a 9 ft tree.

• Choose the Elf Stor Premium Red bag if you already break your tree down each year and want a straightforward zip bag with carry handles and an ID tag.
• Choose the TreeKeeper Upright bag if you want to keep your tree assembled, roll it away on its dolly and store it standing in a corner.