Ellswos-Sports Men's Winter Ski Jacket vs Hamilton Mens Padded Parka

Buy the Hamilton if warmth and everyday winter wear matter most: its chunky recycled-polyester padding and wind-resistant shell suit cold, dry city days, and 300 ratings at 4.7 back it. Buy the Ellswos-Sports if you actually ski or snowboard or get caught in rain: its 150D fabric is fully waterproof, not just water repellent, and it has a detachable adjustable hood and hook-and-loop cuffs. The Hamilton is the better-looking, better-loved coat; the Ellswos is the more technical shell.

• Choose the Ellswos-Sports ski jacket if you need real waterproofing, a detachable hood and cuff straps for skiing, snowboarding or wet weather.
• Choose the Hamilton padded parka if you want a warm, wind-resistant everyday winter coat with a cleaner look and stronger owner ratings.