Ellswos-Sports Men's Winter Ski Jacket vs Men's Black Puffer Jacket

Buy the Ellswos-Sports ski jacket if you actually ski, snowboard or spend hours in rain and snow. Its 150D shell, taped waterproof and windproof build, fleece lining and detachable adjustable hood are made for active winter weather. The Lakeside puffer is the better pick for commuting, errands and everyday cold: Thermocore insulation, a high-neck collar, rib cuffs and a drawcord hem keep heat in with a cleaner look. Owners rate the Ellswos 4.5 from 189 ratings; the puffer has no comparable rating here, so judge it on its spec sheet.

• Choose the Ellswos-Sports ski jacket if you need a waterproof, windproof shell for skiing, snowboarding or wet winter days and want a detachable hood and fleece-lined warmth.
• Choose the Lakeside puffer if you want a lighter, roomier everyday coat for commuting and errands, with a high neck, rib cuffs and a drawcord hem to trap heat.