Energizer LED Camping Lantern, D Battery Powered vs Dorcy Adventure Max Series 41-3120 Lantern
Buy the Dorcy Adventure Max if you need maximum brightness for a campsite or large room; its 3000 lumens dwarf the Energizer's 500. Buy the Energizer if you want a lighter, AA-or-D lantern with a USB charging port and a night-light mode for outages. The Energizer is the more versatile emergency light; the Dorcy is the more powerful area light.
Ask our shopping agent
Energizer LED Camping Lantern, D Battery Powered
Choose the Energizer LED Camping Lantern if you want a lighter, water-resistant lantern that runs on AA or D batteries, has a USB out port to charge a phone, and offers a soft night-light mode.
Pros
- Runs on AA or D batteries, so you can use what you have on hand
- USB out port charges a phone during an outage
- Night-light mode and glow-in-the-dark switch help in the dark
- IPX4 water resistance and lighter body
Cons
- Only 500 lumens, far dimmer than the Dorcy
- Batteries not included
- 30-hour high runtime is a third of the Dorcy's
What separates them
| Energizer LED Camping Lantern, D Battery Powered | Dorcy Adventure Max Series 41-3120 Lantern | |
|---|---|---|
| Brightness | 500 lumens on high | 3000 lumens |
| Runtime on high | Up to 30 hours | Up to 100 hours |
| Battery setup | 3 D or 3 AA, not included | 6 D, included |
| Phone charging | USB out port | None |
| Light modes | High, low, night light | Single push-button output |
| Weight | About 1.5 lb without batteries | 2.29 lb |
| Hanging | Wall-mount and hands-free use | Collapsible metal handle and carabiner hook |
Price history
- Energizer LED Camping Lantern, D Battery Powered: lowest $14.77 on Nov 2 at BrandsMart USA.
- Dorcy Adventure Max Series 41-3120 Lantern: lowest $48.15 on Nov 2 at eBay.
Prices at every store
Energizer LED Camping Lantern, D Battery Powered
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- BrandsMart USACheck price at BrandsMart USA
- eBayCheck price at eBay
Dorcy Adventure Max Series 41-3120 Lantern
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- Hardware & ToolsCheck price at Hardware & Tools
- Home and Country USACheck price at Home and Country USA
Specs compared
| Spec | Energizer LED Camping Lantern, D Battery Powered | Dorcy Adventure Max Series 41-3120 Lantern |
|---|---|---|
| Battery Type | AA | D |
| Primary Material | Plastic | — |
| Location | Wall Mount | — |
| Size | Energizer LED Camping Lantern Flashlight, Batte… | — |
| Color | Red | — |
| Style | OUTDOORRECREATIONPRODUCT | — |
| Finish | Powder Coated | — |
| Shape | Lantern | — |
| Theme | Emergency | — |
| Height | 10.2 in | — |
| Depth |
What reviewers say
Energizer LED Camping Lantern, D Battery Powered
Owner feedback on this lantern line is generally positive, with people praising the brightness and the long low-mode runtime for outages. Complaints tend to focus on battery drain and the plastic build.
Pros
- Bright 500-lumen output for its size
- Long runtime on the low setting
- Handy USB port for charging a phone
- Easy-to-find glow switch
Cons
- Eats batteries on high
- Plastic construction feels light
- USB charging is slow
Questions and answers
- Which is brighter, the Energizer or the Dorcy?
- The Dorcy. It puts out 3000 lumens against the Energizer's 500, about six times the light.
- Which lasts longer on one set of batteries?
- The Dorcy, at up to 100 hours on high versus up to 30 hours for the Energizer. The Energizer's low mode stretches to 90 hours.
- Can I charge my phone with either lantern?
- Only the Energizer. It has a USB out port; the Dorcy has no charging output.
- Which is better for a power outage at home?
- The Energizer. Its night-light mode, AA-or-D flexibility and phone charging suit indoor outages better than the Dorcy's single bright setting.
- Do the batteries come included?
- The Dorcy ships with six D cells. The Energizer does not include batteries; you supply 3 D or 3 AA.
- Is the Dorcy worth it over the Energizer for camping?
- Yes if you need to light a whole site or a group area. The Energizer is enough for a tent or a table and weighs less.
More comparisons
- Dorcy Adventure Max Series 41-3120 Lantern vs Dorcy Adventure Max Series 41-3119 Lantern with Emergency Signaling
- Dorcy Adventure Max Series 41-3120 Lantern vs Coleman 4D LED Camping Lantern
- Energizer LED Camping Lantern, D Battery Powered vs Coleman 4D LED Camping Lantern
- Energizer LED Camping Lantern, D Battery Powered vs Dorcy Adventure Max Series 41-3119 Lantern with Emergency Signaling
