Faux Leather Counter Height Saddle Bar Stools (Set of 2) vs Winsome Ivy Square Leg Stool
Buy the Nathan James Arlo set if you want two padded, easy-to-clean stools for a counter and a 275 lb weight limit. Buy the Winsome Ivy if you want a single, no-assembly wooden stool for a bar-height surface and want to spend as little as possible. The Arlo set is $117.31 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026, which works out to about $59 per stool. The Winsome Ivy is $45.41 at Home Depot as of November 3, 2026, for one stool.
Today the Winsome Ivy Square Leg Stool costs $71.90 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
Faux Leather Counter Height Saddle Bar Stools (Set of 2)
4.9Choose the Nathan James Arlo set if you need two matching padded stools for a 36-inch counter and want wipe-clean faux leather.
- Two stools for about $59 each
- Padded seat is comfortable for longer sitting
- Faux leather wipes clean
- 275 lb weight limit
- Floor protectors included
What separates them
| Faux Leather Counter Height Saddle Bar Stools (Set of 2) | Winsome Ivy Square Leg Stool | |
|---|---|---|
| Seat height | 27.2 in, counter height | 29.1 in, bar height |
| Price per stool | About $59 (set of 2 for $117.31 at Amazon, November 3, 2026) | $45.41 at Home Depot, November 3, 2026 |
| Seat | Padded foam seat in PU leather, 19.3 x 15.4 in | Unpadded round wood seat, about 13 in across |
| Weight limit | 275 lb | 220 lb |
| Assembly | About 30 minutes, hardware included | None required |
| Frame | Metal | Solid wood with weathered teal finish |
| Quantity | Set of 2 | Sold as 1 |
| Floor protection |
Price history
- Faux Leather Counter Height Saddle Bar Stools (Set of 2): lowest $64.99 on Nov 4 at Walmart.
- Winsome Ivy Square Leg Stool: lowest $45.41 on Nov 4 at Home Depot.
Prices at every store
Faux Leather Counter Height Saddle Bar Stools (Set of 2)
- AmazonNew
Availability unknown
As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.
$117.31Free shippingObserved at 10:16 PM - WalmartNew
Out of stockSold by Sweet & Cozy Space
$64.99Observed at 10:16 PM
Also available at
- Nathan JamesCheck price at Nathan James
Winsome Ivy Square Leg Stool
- Home DepotNew
In stock
$45.41Free shippingObserved at 10:16 PM - WalmartNew
In stock
$55.62Observed at 10:16 PM - Lowe'sNew
Availability unknown
$45.41Free shippingObserved at 10:16 PM - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.
$65.35Free shippingObserved at 10:16 PM
Also available at
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- WalmartCheck price at Walmart
Specs compared
| Spec | Faux Leather Counter Height Saddle Bar Stools (Set of 2) | Winsome Ivy Square Leg Stool |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Metal, Leather | Wood |
| Color | Brown | Red |
| Seat Height | 24 inches seat | 29.1 in |
| Backless | Yes | — |
| Saddle Style | Yes | — |
| Quantity | 2 Pieces | — |
| Actual Color | Brown | — |
| Multipack Quantity | 2 | — |
| size | One Siae | — |
| Stool type | — | Bar Height Bar Stools |
| Seat back height descriptor |
What reviewers say
Faux Leather Counter Height Saddle Bar Stools (Set of 2)
Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 87 ratings, buyers are largely happy with the Arlo set. The common themes are easy assembly, a clean look and seats that are simple to wipe down.
- Straightforward assembly
- Looks good at the counter
- Easy to clean
- Sturdy for the price
- Seat height confusion
- No backrest
Winsome Ivy Square Leg Stool
Rated 5 out of 5 from 19 ratings, owners mostly praise the look, the sturdiness and the fact that it needs no assembly.
- Attractive two-tone finish
- Sturdy and stable for the price
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a kitchen island?
- The Arlo set. Its 27.2 in seat fits a standard 36-inch counter, and you get two padded stools. The Winsome Ivy at 29.1 in is bar height and better suits a 40 to 42-inch surface.
- Which is more comfortable for long sitting?
- The Arlo. It has a foam-padded seat; the Winsome Ivy seat is bare wood with no cushion.
- Is the Winsome Ivy worth the savings?
- If you need one stool and no padding, yes. At $45.41 at Home Depot as of November 3, 2026, it costs less than one Arlo stool, but you give up the cushion and 55 lb of weight capacity.
- Which holds more weight?
- The Arlo, at 275 lb versus 220 lb for the Winsome Ivy.
- Do either need assembly?
- The Winsome Ivy arrives ready to use. The Arlo takes about 30 minutes with the included hardware.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Winsome Ivy's solid wood frame has fewer wear points. The Arlo's PU leather is the part most likely to show wear first, though its metal frame is sturdy.
