Which is better for a kitchen island?

The Arlo set. Its 27.2-inch seat height fits a standard 36-inch counter, and the padded seats suit daily meals. The Winsome Ivy at 29.1 inches is meant for 40 to 42-inch bar counters.

The Arlo has a metal frame rated to 275 lb and fabric tested to over 100,000 double rubs. The Winsome Ivy is solid wood rated to 220 lb. Both should hold up for years indoors; the Arlo carries a higher weight rating.

Is the Arlo set worth the extra money?

Yes if you need four stools. Four Winsome Ivy stools cost about $182, so the Arlo set adds roughly $80 for padding, a higher weight limit and a matched look.

Do I need to assemble either one?

The Winsome Ivy arrives ready to use. The Arlo needs assembly, about 60 minutes for the set, with hardware and instructions included.

Which is easier to clean?

The Arlo. Its faux leather wipes clean in seconds. The Winsome Ivy is bare wood, so wipe spills promptly to protect the finish.

Which is better for a small space?

The Winsome Ivy. Its 13-inch round seat and flared legs tuck under a counter, and at 8.3 lb it is easy to move. The Arlo stools are bulkier at 19.3 inches wide.

Upholstered Counter Height Saddle Bar Stools Gray (Set of 4) vs Winsome Ivy Square Leg Stool

Buy the Nathan James Arlo set of 4 if you need a matched set of upholstered counter stools for a kitchen island. Buy the Winsome Ivy if you want one cheap, colorful, no-assembly stool for a bar-height counter. The Arlo set is $262.11 at The Home Depot as of November 4, 2026, about $65.53 per stool. The Winsome Ivy is $45.41 at Home Depot as of November 4, 2026, for a single stool.

Today the Winsome Ivy Square Leg Stool costs $216.70 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent