Which is better for highway driving?

Both are T-rated all-season tires with the same size and load index. The Firestone markets a quiet, low-noise ride, while the Goodyear's 600 treadwear rating suggests longer tread life. For mostly highway miles, the Goodyear is the better value at $124.99.

The Goodyear carries a 600 UTQG treadwear rating, which is the comparable figure here; the Firestone does not publish one. The Firestone backs its tire with a 65,000-mile warranty, so warranty coverage favors it even if the treadwear number is unknown.

Is the Firestone worth the extra $13?

Only if the 65,000-mile warranty and quiet-ride claims matter more to you than the Goodyear's lower price and 600 treadwear rating. On price and published treadwear, the Goodyear wins.

Do both fit the same wheels?

Yes. Both are 235/55R17 with a 99 load index and T speed rating, so they fit the same vehicles. Confirm fitment against your car's door placard before ordering.

Why is the Firestone rated so low?

It scores 2.9 out of 5 from 27 ratings, which is a small sample and below what most all-season tires earn. The Goodyear has no shopper rating shown, so there is no direct comparison.

Which is better in wet weather?

The Firestone advertises enhanced wet traction. The Goodyear's UTQG traction grade is A, which is a solid wet-braking rating. Neither is a dedicated wet tire; both are standard all-season compounds.

Firestone All Season 235/55R17 vs Assurance All-Season

The Goodyear Assurance All-Season is the better buy for most shoppers: it costs less at $124.99 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026 versus $138.06 at Walmart for the Firestone, and it carries a stronger 600 A B UTQG treadwear rating. The Firestone All Season has a thin 2.9-out-of-5 rating from 27 ratings and a shorter 65,000-mile warranty, so it only makes sense if you find it discounted well below the Goodyear. Both are T-rated 235/55R17 all-season tires with a 99 load index, so fitment is the same.

Today the Assurance All-Season costs $13.07 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent