TOYO Extensa HP2 vs Assurance All-Season
Buy the TOYO Extensa HP2 if you want a sportier all-season tire at a lower price: $87.94 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026, versus $124.99 at Amazon for the Goodyear Assurance All-Season. Buy the Goodyear if you want a long-wear, comfortable highway tire for a vehicle like a 2006 Toyota Highlander and don't need a W speed rating. The TOYO is the better value for grip and handling; the Goodyear is the safer pick for treadwear and ride comfort.
Today the TOYO Extensa HP2 costs $37.05 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
TOYO Extensa HP2
$87.94at AmazonObserved Nov 2, 2026, 6:16 PM
Choose the TOYO Extensa HP2 if you drive a sporty car or want sharper dry and wet handling with a 168 mph W speed rating at a lower price.
Pros
- W speed rating up to 168 mph
- Lowest price of the two at $87.94
- Hydroplaning resistance and enhanced dry traction
- Quiet ride with low rolling resistance
- XL load capacity
Cons
- One reviewer reported tread and sidewall failure within 50 miles
- Ride is firm at first
- No UTQG treadwear figure given
What separates them
| TOYO Extensa HP2 | Assurance All-Season | |
|---|---|---|
| Price (best new) | $87.94 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026 | $124.99 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026 |
| Speed rating | W (up to 168 mph) | T (up to 118 mph) |
| UTQG treadwear | Not stated in the listing | 600 |
| Load index | 97 XL | 99 |
| Size listed | 235/45R17 | 235/55R17 |
| Category | High-performance all-season | Standard touring all-season |
| Ride focus | Quiet ride, low rolling resistance, firm initially | Comfort-oriented highway/city touring |
| Durability reports | One report of tread and sidewall failure within 50 miles |
Price history
- TOYO Extensa HP2: lowest $87.94 on Nov 2 at Amazon.
- Assurance All-Season: lowest $124.99 on Nov 2 at Amazon.
Prices at every store
TOYO Extensa HP2
- Tire MarksNew
In stockReturn policy
$165.78Observed Nov 2, 2026, 6:17 PM - Wheel WarehouseNew
In stockReturn policy
$165.78Observed Nov 2, 2026, 6:17 PM - American Wheel GuysNew
In stockReturn policy
$199.99Observed Nov 2, 2026, 6:17 PM - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
$87.94Free shippingObserved Nov 2, 2026, 6:16 PM
Also available at
- 1010Tires.comCheck price at 1010Tires.com
- Belle TireCheck price at Belle Tire
- VIPCheck price at VIP
Specs compared
| Spec | TOYO Extensa HP2 | Assurance All-Season |
|---|---|---|
| Season | All-Season | — |
| Item Type | Tire | — |
| Dry Grip | Enhanced dry traction | — |
| Wet Grip | Hydroplaning resistance | — |
| Wheel / Tire | Tire | — |
| Subtype | Performance, High-performance | — |
| Tire Type | Radial | — |
| Aspect Ratio | 45 | — |
| Diameter | 17 inch | — |
| Load Index | 97 | — |
| Section Width | 235 mm | — |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a sporty car?
- The TOYO Extensa HP2. Its W rating and high-performance all-season compound suit faster cars and sharper handling. The Goodyear's T rating and touring focus are built for comfort, not cornering.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Goodyear Assurance All-Season carries a 600 UTQG treadwear rating, which points to longer tread life. The TOYO listing gives no UTQG figure, and one reviewer reported early tread and sidewall failure.
- Is the Goodyear worth the extra $37?
- If you want treadwear and a softer highway ride, yes. If you want grip and a higher speed rating, the TOYO at $87.94 is the better buy.
- Which is better in snow?
- The TOYO lists light-snow suitability and reviewers praise its snow grip. The Goodyear is an all-season tire without a snow claim in the listing, so the TOYO has the edge for occasional snow.
- Will either fit a 2006 Toyota Highlander?
- The Goodyear listing names the 2006 Highlander Limited and its 235/55R17 size matches that vehicle. The TOYO shown is 235/45R17, a smaller sidewall, so check your door placard before buying.
- Which is quieter?
- The TOYO is described as having a quiet ride, though some reviewers found it firm at first. The Goodyear is a touring tire tuned for comfort, so expect it to be at least as quiet on the highway.