Fluff & Tuff Sadie the Bear vs FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy

Buy the Fluff & Tuff Sadie the Bear for a large or giant dog that plays hard and needs a big, tough plush. Its Tuffweb mesh liner, double-stitched concealed seams and embroidered eyes hold up better to tugging than the FabDog, and it can go in the washing machine. The FabDog Fluffy Orangutan is the better pick for a small or medium dog, or for a dog that likes a noisy toy: it packs four squeakers and a grunter into a shaggy body. Owners of both praise the softness, but the FabDog's spot-clean-only care and lighter lining make it the less durable of the two.

• Choose the Fluff & Tuff Sadie the Bear if you have a large or giant dog that tugs, shakes and cuddles a big plush and you want one you can machine wash.
• Choose the FabDog Fluffy Orangutan if you have a small or medium dog that stays engaged with squeakers and a grunter, and you want a soft, shaggy toy in a smaller size.