Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

BARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog Toy vs FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy

Pick the BARK Sleepytime Fluffy if your dog likes to rip, dig for treats and share toys with other dogs. Its four-part build, disc squeakers, crinkle and treat trap give more to do, and owners say dogs play with it constantly. The FabDog Fluffy Orangutan is the simpler, sturdier cuddler: one piece, four squeakers plus a grunter, and a reinforced nylon lining that holds up better to chewing. Choose the BARK for active, destructive play; choose FabDog for a soft comfort toy that lasts.

  • Choose the Sleepytime Fluffy if your dog is a ripper and forager who wants treat hiding, crinkle and multiple squeaky pieces, especially in a multi-dog home.
  • Choose the FabDog Fluffy Orangutan if you want one soft, well-lined plush with plenty of squeakers and a grunter for a dog that mostly cuddles and chews.

Prices

  • BARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog Toy: $27.99 at BARK (last seen Nov 4)
  • FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy: $14.99 at sgsnaples.com (checked today)
  • Difference: the FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy is $13.00 cheaper than the BARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog Toy at the latest prices (Nov 4 and Nov 9)
S
Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Extra-Large + Multi-Part + Enrichment Dog Toy

BARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog Toy

Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Extra-Large + Multi-Part + Enrichment Dog Toy

5(1 rating)
$27.99at BARKObserved Nov 4, 2026, 5:01 PM
See all prices and details
Visit BARK
Pros
  • Four separate pieces extend play and spread across dogs
  • Treat trap adds foraging work
  • Crinkle plus squeakers keep dogs engaged
  • Extra-large size suits big dogs and tug
Cons
  • No reinforced lining, so heavy chewers can gut it fast
  • Ripping is the point, so it comes apart by design
  • Stuffing cleanup after destruction
FabDog
FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy

FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy

$14.99at sgsnaples.comObserved at 1:21 AM
See all prices and details
Visit sgsnaples.com
Pros
  • Reinforced nylon lining resists chewing better
  • Four squeakers and a grunter give varied sound
  • Soft shaggy plush doubles as a cuddle toy
  • Easy spot cleaning
Cons
  • No treat pocket or crinkle
  • Single piece, less variety for multi-dog play
  • Smaller sizes may be too little for large breeds

What separates them

BARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog ToyFabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy
ConstructionMulti-part toy with 4 pieces that rip apart to reveal surprisesSingle-piece plush
Noise featuresDisc squeakers plus Crazy Crinkle4 squeakers plus 1 grunter
Treat playBuilt-in treat trap for hiding treatsNo treat pocket
Durability liningPlush shell, no reinforced liner listedReinforced nylon Fabtough lining
SizeXL, about 16" tallSmall 11" or Large 14.2" tall
Best play styleTug, fetch, treat hiding, multi-dog householdsSnuggling, solo chewing, interactive play
CleaningNot specifiedSpot clean with soap and water

Price history

  • BARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog Toy: lowest $27.99 on Nov 4 at BARK.
  • FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy: lowest $14.99 on Nov 9 at sgsnaples.com.

Prices at every store

BARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog Toy

  • BARKNew

    Availability unknown

    $27.99Observed Nov 4, 2026, 5:01 PM
    Visit BARK

Also available at

  • BARKCheck price at BARK
Prices and history →

FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy

  • Jenna Kays PlaceNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $18.99Observed at 1:21 AM
    Visit Jenna Kays Place
  • Brookside Barkery & BathNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $18.99Observed at 1:21 AM
    Visit Brookside Barkery & Bath
  • sgsnaples.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $14.99Observed at 1:21 AM
    Visit sgsnaples.com
  • The Mill in GermansvilleNew

    Availability unknown

    $18.99Observed at 1:21 AM
    Visit The Mill in Germansville

Also available at

  • Brookside Barkery & BathCheck price at Brookside Barkery & Bath
  • Pawsitive Pet ProductsCheck price at Pawsitive Pet Products
All 13 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecBARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog ToyFabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy
SqueakersDisc Squeakersfour squeakers
TypePlush—
SizeExtra Large: 12.8"D x 14.8"W x 16"H—
Toy PartsMulti-Part Toy (4)—
Crinkle FeatureCrazy Crinkle—
Treat FeatureTreat Trap—
Small height—11" Height
Large height—14.2" Height
Grunter—one grunter
Squeaker type—grunting squeaker
Lining—reinforced nylon lining
Fill—Poly fill
Show all 13 specsShow fewer specs
SpecBARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog ToyFabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy
Cleaning—Spot clean with soap and water

What reviewers say

BARK Sleepytime Fluffy Plush Dog Toy

Buyers say dogs play with it constantly and it quickly became a favorite. Owners like the Harry Potter design and the three-headed Fluffy shape, and report it is a hit with every dog in the house.

What people mention
  • DurabilityMixedBuyers love the plush, but a rippable multi-part toy is not built for heavy chewers.
  • EngagementPraisedOwners say dogs play with it constantly and it quickly became a favorite.
  • DesignPraisedThe Harry Potter Fluffy shape is called adorable and unique.
  • Multi-dog usePraisedReported as a hit with all the dogs in a household.

FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy

Owners of FabDog fluffy plush toys tend to praise the softness and the mix of squeakers and grunter, and many dogs take to them quickly as carry-around toys. The recurring complaint is durability: dogs that chew hard can open seams and pull out stuffing within days.

What people mention
  • DurabilityCriticisedOwners say the plush shell and seams can tear once a dog chews hard, with stuffing coming out.
  • SqueakersMixedThe multiple squeakers and grunter are a hit at first, but some report they stop working after rough play.
  • SoftnessPraisedReviewers describe the shaggy plush as very soft and say dogs like to cuddle and carry it.
  • Chew resistanceMixedThe reinforced lining helps with tugging and light chewing, but it is not a match for determined chewers.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a dog that destroys plush toys?
The FabDog Orangutan. Its reinforced nylon lining holds up longer against chewing. The BARK Sleepytime is built to be ripped apart, so expect it to come apart.
Which has more to keep a dog busy?
The BARK Sleepytime. It has a treat trap, crinkle and four rip-out pieces. The FabDog has more squeakers but no treat hiding or crinkle.
Which is better for multiple dogs?
The BARK Sleepytime. Its four pieces can be shared, and it is rated for multi-dog households. The FabDog is one toy, so dogs compete for it.
Which is softer for a dog that likes to cuddle?
The FabDog Orangutan. Its shaggy plush and polyfill make it a comfort toy first. The BARK is bigger but built around noisy, active play.
Is the FabDog worth stepping up to over the BARK?
Yes if durability matters most. The lining is the main upgrade. Skip it if your dog wants treat puzzles and ripping.
How big are they?
The BARK Sleepytime is extra large at about 16 inches tall. The FabDog comes in 11-inch small and 14.2-inch large.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Sleepytime Fluffy Plush XXL Multi-Part + Enrichment Dog Toy vs FabDog Fluffy Orangutan Plush Dog Toy

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best fluffy plush dog toys