Freja NYC Chrystie Bag vs Poppy & Peonies Everyday Crossbody

The Freja NYC Chrystie is a wide, flat shoulder bag with a foldover magnetic top and four interior slip pockets; it suits someone who carries a tablet, folder or small laptop and wants a clean, structured look. The Poppy & Peonies Everyday Crossbody is a smaller, convertible 4-in-1 bag with a removable wristlet clutch, card slots and an adjustable crossbody strap; it suits someone who wants hands-free carry and built-in organization. On materials, the Chrystie is faux leather throughout, while the Everyday Crossbody pairs a dyed calf leather main body with a cotton lining and leather trim, so it has the edge on materials. Owners of the Everyday Crossbody rate it highly and praise the compartments and removable clutch, but some report strap defects and a sharp expansion zipper. The Chrystie's magnetic lock and flat shape are simpler and less fussy.

• Choose the Freja NYC Chrystie if you want a roomy, structured shoulder bag that holds larger items and opens with a foldover magnetic top.
• Choose the Everyday Crossbody if you want a hands-free crossbody with a removable wristlet clutch, card slots and an adjustable strap.