Frigidaire EFIC130-SS Bullet Ice Maker vs Igloo Premium Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker

Both are countertop bullet-ice machines rated 4.3, so the choice comes down to build and features. The Frigidaire has a stainless steel body, a larger reservoir and a much bigger track record of owner ratings; the Igloo adds a five-cycle self-clean function and two cube sizes in a lighter plastic shell. Buy the Frigidaire for a sturdier machine you fill less often; buy the Igloo if self-cleaning matters more than finish.

• Choose the Frigidaire if you want a stainless steel body, a bigger water tank and a model with thousands of owner ratings behind it.
• Choose the Igloo if you want automatic self-cleaning and a choice of two cube sizes and can live with a plastic body.