Frigidaire Compact Countertop Ice Maker vs Newair Countertop Ice Maker

Both are countertop bullet-or-cube ice makers with strong owner ratings, but they suit different kitchens. The Frigidaire is lighter and simpler, with a retro look and a see-through window; it makes cubed ice in two sizes and stores about 1.5 lb. The Newair is the heavier, more capable machine: three ice sizes, a self-cleaning cycle, a side drain and BPA-free parts, and its published cycle runs about 6 minutes. Owners of both praise the convenience; the common complaints are noise and ice melting in the bin. Buy the Newair if you want self-cleaning and more size options; buy the Frigidaire if you want a lighter, simpler unit.

• Choose the Frigidaire if you want a lighter, simpler countertop maker with cubed ice, two sizes and a clear window to watch the bin.
• Choose the Newair if you want self-cleaning, three ice sizes, a side drain and BPA-free parts in a sturdier machine.