StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Frye Melissa Button 2 Boots vs Frye Billy Pull On

The Billy Pull On is the better boot. Goodyear welt construction means the sole can be replaced, and the mid-calf shaft is easier to pull on than the Melissa's 15.5-inch shaft with no zipper. The Melissa Button 2 has the classic equestrian look and a lower 1-inch heel, but its 3.5-star rating reflects real complaints about thin leather and soles separating within months. Choose the Billy for durability and everyday wear; choose the Melissa only if you want the tall riding-boot silhouette.

  • Choose the Melissa Button 2 if you want a tall equestrian boot with a low block heel and the signature Frye button detail.
  • Choose the Billy Pull On if you want a resolable Western boot that holds up to daily wear.

Prices

  • Frye Melissa Button 2 Boots: $79.99 at eBay (last seen Nov 9)
  • Frye Billy Pull On: $199.98 at Amazon (checked today)
  • Difference: the Frye Melissa Button 2 Boots is $119.99 cheaper than the Frye Billy Pull On at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 17)
Frye
Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots

Frye Melissa Button 2 Boots

Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots

3.5(467 ratings)
$79.99at eBayChecked Nov 9
See all prices and details
Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

Pros
  • Classic equestrian styling with the Frye button detail
  • Low 1-inch heel is comfortable for long wear
  • Leather lining and leather outsole
  • Tall shaft suits skirts and dresses
Cons
  • Sole separation reported within three months
  • Leather criticized as below Frye standards
  • No zipper makes them hard to get on and off
  • Color often differs from photos
Frye
Frye Billy Pull On

Frye Billy Pull On

$199.98at AmazonChecked 6 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission. As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

Pros
  • Goodyear welt construction can be resoled
  • Pull-on design is easy to put on
  • Pointed toe and chunky heel give a Western look
  • Pull-up leather and leather lining
Cons
  • Pointed toe is less roomy than a round toe
  • 1.5-inch heel is higher and less stable for all-day standing
  • Mid-calf shaft offers less coverage in cold weather
  • Fewer owner reviews to judge long-term wear

What separates them

Frye Melissa Button 2 BootsFrye Billy Pull On
ConstructionCemented sole; owners report the sole separating in under three monthsGoodyear welt, so the sole can be replaced by a cobbler
Shaft height15.5 inches, knee-high11.5 inches, mid-calf
Heel1-inch low block heel1.5-inch chunky Western heel
Toe shapeRound toePointed toe
Getting them onNo zipper; owners say they are hard to pull on and offPull-on tabs with a wider opening
Calf fit14.5-inch circumference; owners report sizing and calf fit problems13.5-inch circumference, slimmer fit
LeatherVegetable smooth leather; some owners say it feels cheap for FryeRich pull-up leather
Owner satisfaction3.5 out of 5 from 467 ratingsNo rating data available

Price history

$229.98$84.99
Nov 3Nov 17
  • Frye Melissa Button 2 Boots: lowest $84.99 on Nov 17 at Jender.
  • Frye Billy Pull On: lowest $199.98 on Nov 17 at Amazon.

Prices at every store

Frye Melissa Button 2 Boots

  • PoshmarkNew

    In stock

    $125.00Checked Nov 9
    Visit Poshmark
  • PoshmarkNew

    In stock

    $150.00+ $0.99 shippingChecked 6 h ago
    Visit Poshmark
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownReturns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.

    $79.99Free shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit eBay
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $159.98Free shippingChecked 6 h ago
    Visit Amazon

Also available at

  • eBayCheck price at eBay
  • The Frye CompanyCheck price at The Frye Company
  • Dress CodeCheck price at Dress Code

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 12 stores and price history →

Frye Billy Pull On

  • Snyders ShoesNew

    In stock

    $358.00+ $14.00 shippingChecked 6 h ago
    Visit Snyders Shoes
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $199.98Free shippingChecked 6 h ago
    Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecFrye Melissa Button 2 BootsFrye Billy Pull On
Shaft height15.5"11.5"
Calf circumference14.5"13.5"
Heel height1"1.5"
Upper materialVegetable smooth leatherSmooth leather
Toe shapeRound toePointed toe
LiningLeather liningLeather lining
OutsoleLeather outsoleLeather outsole
Shaft circumference14 1/2"—
HardwareAntique silver hardware—
Country of originMade in Mexico—
Size (US)10—
Heel TypeLow Heel, Block Heel—
Show all 16 specsShow fewer specs
SpecFrye Melissa Button 2 BootsFrye Billy Pull On
ColorMulticolor—
Age GroupAdult—
GenderFemale—
Construction—Goodyear welt construction

What reviewers say

Frye Melissa Button 2 Boots

  • 3.5 / 5467 ratings

Frye Billy Pull On

Owners of Frye Western boots generally rate the leather and build highly and treat them as long-term boots. The common complaints are a stiff break-in and a narrow, pointed fit.

What people mention
  • Break-inCriticisedOwners say the boots feel stiff out of the box and need several wears to soften.
  • Build qualityPraisedReviewers point to the Goodyear welt and leather throughout as signs of a boot built to last.
  • FitMixedThe pointed toe suits some feet well but feels tight for wider feet.
  • TractionCriticisedThe leather outsole is described as slippery on wet pavement.

Questions and answers

Which is better for everyday wear?
The Billy Pull On. Its Goodyear welt lets a cobbler replace the sole, and the pull-on design is quicker to put on. The Melissa's cemented sole has drawn complaints about separation.
Which lasts longer?
The Billy. Goodyear welt construction is built to be repaired and resoled. The Melissa Button 2 is cemented, and owners report soles coming undone within months.
Is the Melissa Button 2 worth stepping up to?
Only if you want the tall riding-boot look. It costs more in build quality terms than the Billy, with a cemented sole and thinner-feeling leather, so it is not an upgrade in durability.
Which is easier to get on?
The Billy. It is a pull-on boot with a shorter 11.5-inch shaft. The Melissa has no zipper and a 15.5-inch shaft, and owners say it is hard to get on and off.
Which fits wider calves?
The Melissa, at a 14.5-inch calf circumference versus 13.5 inches on the Billy. Even so, Melissa owners report calf fit problems, so measure before you buy.
Which has a more comfortable heel?
The Melissa's 1-inch low block heel is flatter and steadier for standing. The Billy's 1.5-inch chunky heel is still stable but sits higher.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Frye Veronica vs Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots
  • Frye Campus 14L vs Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots
  • Frye Veronica vs Frye Billy Pull On
  • Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots vs Frye Harness Boots
  • Frye Kate Harness Leather Boot vs Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots
  • Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots vs Frye Campus Knee High Boot
  • Frye Campus 14in Leather Wide Calf Boot vs Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots
  • Frye Campus 14L vs Frye Billy Pull On

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best Frye women's leather boots
  • Best Frye women's boots