Which is better for a high-traffic living room?

Both are rated for high-traffic indoor use and have non-slip backing. The Garland's 0.3 in loop pile feels more substantial, while the flat weave is easier to pull up and wash.

Is the washable rug worth about $199 more?

Only if machine washing is a must. At $239.98 at Walmart versus $41.07 at Kohl's as of November 8, 2026, you pay roughly five times as much for washability and a softer, thinner pile.

The Garland's tufted polypropylene with bound edges is built for years of foot traffic, though loop pile can snag. The flat weave is durable but thin, and repeated washing may wear it faster.

Do either need a rug pad?

Neither strictly needs one; both have non-slip backing. A pad still adds cushioning and extends life, especially under the thin flat weave.

Which is better with pets?

The washable rug is easier to clean after accidents since it can go in a machine. The Garland resists stains but its loop pile can catch claws.

Garland Rug Classic Berber Square Rug vs 12×12 Square Washable Area Rug

Buy the Garland Rug Classic Berber if you want a 12x12 square rug at the lowest price: $41.07 at Kohl's as of November 8, 2026, against $239.98 at Walmart for the washable rug. Choose the washable flat-woven rug if machine washing and a softer, thinner pile matter more than the roughly $199 price gap. Both are beige, non-slip, stain-resistant indoor squares, so the real decision is price versus washability.

Today the Garland Rug Classic Berber Square Rug costs $198.91 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.