Which is better for a high-traffic living room?

Both are built for high-traffic areas with stain-resistant polypropylene and non-slip backing. The Berber's level loop pile holds up better against crushing; the Medallion's cut loop feels softer but can mat.

Is the Medallion worth the extra money?

Only if you want the sage green color or the OEKO-TEX certification. Otherwise the Berber does the same job for about $13 less at current prices.

Expect similar life from both: same brand, same material, same 0.3 in pile. The Berber's loop pile is less prone to shedding and matting than the Medallion's cut pile.

Do either of these work on hardwood floors?

Yes. Both have non-slip latex backing, and the Berber is listed for hard surfaces where it is less likely to bunch or crease.

Are they machine washable?

No. Both are spot clean only, with regular vacuuming. The Berber should be vacuumed without a beater bar.

Do they have a pet-friendly pile?

The Medallion's cut loop is less likely to snag claws. The Berber's loop pile can catch on pet nails, so trim or watch for pulls.

Garland Rug Classic Berber Square Rug vs Garland Rug Medallion Sage Square Rug

Both are 12' x 12' square Garland Rug polypropylene rugs with non-slip latex backing, made in the USA. The Classic Berber is the better value: $41.07 at Kohl's as of November 8, 2026, against $53.84 at eBay for the Medallion. Buy the Berber for a neutral beige farmhouse look and the Medallion for a sage green transitional look.

Today the Garland Rug Classic Berber Square Rug costs $12.77 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.