Which is better for covering gray hair?

Both are full-coverage permanent dyes, so both cover gray. Clairol Nice'n Easy blends three tones plus highlights, which reads more natural on gray; Garnier Nutrisse lays down one rich creme shade.

Both are permanent. Clairol states up to 8 weeks of shiny color; Garnier does not publish a week count, so Clairol is the clearer claim.

Is the Clairol worth the extra 52 cents?

For most shoppers, yes. It has a higher rating from far more ratings, multi-tone color and a bond-strengthening treatment for $9.49 versus $8.97.

Which is gentler on dry hair?

Garnier Nutrisse leans on an avocado-oil and vitamin E conditioner to fight dryness. Clairol's Colorlock treatment focuses on bond strength and sealing color. Neither is ammonia-free; Clairol lists up to 2.65% ammonia.

Which shade matches medium natural brown?

Garnier Nutrisse 50 Medium Natural Brown (Truffle) is a direct medium brown. Clairol Nice'n Easy comes in its own shade range, so match the swatch rather than the number.

Can I switch between the two brands?

Yes, both are permanent full-coverage dyes. Recolor on the schedule each brand gives, and do a patch test before switching.

Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Permanent Hair Color vs Clairol Nice'n Easy Permanent Hair Color

Both are permanent full-coverage drugstore dyes at nearly the same price: $8.97 for Garnier Nutrisse 50 Medium Natural Brown at Amazon and $9.49 for Clairol Nice'n Easy at Amazon as of November 3, 2026. Clairol Nice'n Easy is the safer pick for most shoppers: it has a much larger rating base (26,587 vs 8,316) and a higher score (4.55 vs 4.2), plus multi-tone color and a bond-strengthening treatment. Choose Garnier Nutrisse if you want the lower price or you prefer its avocado- and fruit-oil conditioner and grape-seed scent.

Today the Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Permanent Hair Color costs $0.52 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent