Which is better for covering gray hair?

Both are full-coverage permanent kits, so gray coverage is comparable. Nice'n Easy blends three tones for a more natural gray blend; Excellence Crème gives a more uniform result.

Both are permanent, so color stays until it grows out. Clairol states up to 8 weeks of shiny color for Nice'n Easy; L'Oréal does not state a wear time for Excellence Crème.

Is the ammonia-free one worth it?

Excellence Crème is ammonia-free and costs less at $9.00 versus $9.49. If scalp sensitivity is your main concern, it is the safer pick; if you want dimension, Nice'n Easy delivers more.

Which is better for ash blonde shades?

Excellence Crème. Shade 7.5A Medium Ash Blonde is built to cancel warm and brassy tones, which Nice'n Easy's multi-tone system does less directly.

Which has better shopper feedback?

Nice'n Easy has a visible record: 4.55 out of 5 from 26,587 ratings. Excellence Crème's listing gives no rating count, so there is less to compare.

Do both include everything needed?

Yes. Excellence Crème includes pre-color serum, colorant, developer and conditioner. Nice'n Easy includes colorant, developer and Colorlock Treatment.

L'Oréal Paris Excellence Crème Permanent Hair Color vs Clairol Nice'n Easy Permanent Hair Color

Both are permanent, full-coverage drugstore kits within 49 cents of each other: $9.00 at eBay for Excellence Crème and $9.49 at Amazon for Nice'n Easy, as of November 3, 2026. Choose Excellence Crème for cool ash shades and a gentler ammonia-free formula with a pre-color serum. Choose Nice'n Easy for natural-looking multi-tone color, a bigger track record of ratings, and a lower price per box only if you find it on sale.

Today the L'Oréal Paris Excellence Crème Permanent Hair Color costs $0.49 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent