Georgia Boot Amplitude Waterproof Composite Toe Work Boot vs Caterpillar Second Shift Steel Toe

The Caterpillar Second Shift is the safer pick for most buyers. It has a steel toe plus electrical hazard protection, a steel shank, Goodyear welt construction and a much larger, better-rated owner base. The Georgia Amplitude is the more comfortable boot out of the box, with a memory foam insole, an ergonomic composite toe and a guaranteed waterproof system, but its 3.5 rating from 71 ratings is a warning sign. Pick the Georgia if cushioning and a lighter composite toe matter more to you than track record.

• Choose the Georgia Boot Amplitude if you are on your feet all day, want a soft memory foam insole and a composite toe that will not set off metal detectors.
• Choose the Caterpillar Second Shift if you want a proven steel toe boot with electrical hazard protection, a steel shank and resoleable Goodyear welt construction.