Gericco 89" Mid Century Upholstered Sofa vs Better Homes & Gardens Lillian Tufted Sofa

Buy the Gericco if you want a long, deep three-seater that seats three adults and holds up to heavy use; its steel frame and 750 lb rating are the practical choice for a busy living room. The Better Homes & Gardens Lillian is the better pick for a smaller, styled space where looks matter more than capacity, but its listed 250 lb limit and 18.5-inch seat depth suit one or two lighter sitters, not a full family. On build, the Gericco's metal frame is the sturdier bet; the Lillian leans on a solid wood base and sinuous springs for a more traditional feel.

• Choose the Gericco if you need a wide three-seater with deep seats, a 750 lb capacity and washable cushion covers for daily family use.
• Choose the Lillian if you want a channel-tufted cream sofa with a wood frame and springs for a smaller, styled room with lighter use.