Which is warmer, the Gildan 18500 or the Nike Club Fleece Crewneck?

The Gildan 18500 is warmer. Its 8 oz fleece and double-lined hood trap more heat than Nike's lighter Club Fleece, which has no hood at all.

Is the Gildan 18500 worth it over the Nike for everyday wear?

For everyday wear the Nike is softer and has a cleaner fit. The Gildan wins on price and warmth, so pick it if you layer it or wear it outdoors.

Which one lasts longer?

Both hold up well with machine washing. The Gildan's heavier 50/50 fleece and preshrunk construction resist pilling and size shift, while Nike's higher cotton content can pill faster with heavy wear.

Does the Gildan 18500 run true to size?

It runs roomy and classic, so most shoppers who want a trimmer fit size down. It is available from S to 5XL.

Can I print or embroider the Gildan 18500?

Yes. It is a standard blank for screen printing, DTF, and embroidery, and the set-in sleeves and flat seams help keep prints consistent.

Is the Nike Club Fleece Crewneck worth the extra money?

Only if you want the Nike logo, the softer cotton-rich fabric, and a crewneck silhouette. Otherwise the Gildan costs far less and is warmer.

Gildan G18500 Fleece Hoodie vs Nike Club Fleece Crewneck Sweatshirt

Buy the Gildan 18500 if you want a heavy 8 oz pullover hood for warmth, layering, or printing, and the price is hard to beat: $12.97 at DTF Jersey as of November 5, 2026. Buy the Nike Club Fleece Crewneck if you want a lighter, softer cotton-rich crewneck with a clean embroidered logo and a standard fit, at $65.00 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026. The Gildan costs about a fifth of the Nike, but it is a hoodie, not a crewneck, and its 50/50 fleece feels rougher than Nike's cotton-rich Club Fleece.

Today the Gildan G18500 Fleece Hoodie costs $52.03 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.