Cherished Moments Girls Heart Birthstone Ring vs Cherished Moments Girls Butterfly Birthstone Ring

Both rings are sterling silver children's birthstone rings from the same maker, so build quality is a wash. The Heart ring is the better pick for a very young child or a first ring: it comes in sizes 1 through 5, offers a 14k gold-plated option, and has a flatter heart setting that snags less. The Butterfly ring has a wider size run and a more detailed enamel-and-crystal design, which suits an older girl who wants something more decorative. Owners of the Heart ring report good fit and happy granddaughters; the Butterfly's extra detail is the main reason to step up.

• Choose the Heart Birthstone Ring if you want a simple first ring for a baby or toddler, need a gold-tone option, or want the flatter heart setting that catches less on clothing.
• Choose the Butterfly Birthstone Ring if the girl is older and wants a more decorative enamel-and-crystal design, or if you need a size above 5.