Kids' Heart Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver vs Cherished Moments Girls Heart Birthstone Ring

Both are sterling silver heart birthstone rings for little girls, and both are nickel-free and come in a gift box. The Cherished Moments ring is the more flexible buy: it runs in sizes 1 through 5, covers roughly ages 0-8, offers a 14k gold-plated finish, and has an anti-tarnish coating. The Parkhill ring is a simpler solitaire with a halo of clear cubic zirconia, sized 2-5 and aimed at ages 2-5. Owners of the Cherished Moments ring report good fit and happy recipients; the Parkhill ring carries a high rating but from a small number of reviews.

• Choose the Parkhill Jewelry heart solitaire ring if you want a halo of clear stones around the birthstone heart and a ring sized for a toddler or preschooler.
• Choose the Cherished Moments heart ring if you want sizes down to 1, a gold-plated option, or an anti-tarnish finish for a child who will wear it daily.