Giselle Bedding 21cm Pillow Top Mattress vs Queen Rose 12-Inch Hybrid Mattress

The Queen Rose is the better-built mattress: a 12-inch hybrid with 900+ individually wrapped coils, a bamboo-blend cover, CertiPUR-US certification, a 100-night trial and a 10-year warranty. The Giselle is a basic Bonnell spring pillow top with a knitted cover, no trial and no stated warranty. Buy the Giselle if you want a simple medium-firm pillow-top feel and don't care about a trial or pocket coils. Buy the Queen Rose if you want motion isolation, a firmer feel and real after-sale protection.

• Choose the Giselle if you want a soft-quilted pillow top with a medium-firm feel and a simple Bonnell spring build.
• Choose the Queen Rose if you want pocket coils, a firmer hybrid feel and a 100-night trial backed by a 10-year warranty.